chapter02 · 054-ep54

Chapter 2, Episode 54: The First Expert Committee Meeting

Central Government Building, Tokyo.

2:00 PM. In the conference room, experts in law, crisis management, economics, and dungeon research had gathered, along with former hunters, industry representatives, and officials from relevant ministries and the JHA.

The name of the meeting was "Expert Committee on High-Ranking Hunter Activities and Social Responsibility."

On each seat were materials prepared by the secretariat, and the same title was displayed on the screen at the front. Magami Koichiro's name was not there.

But everyone present knew who currently qualified as the 'high-ranking hunter' to be discussed here today.

"Now then, as it is the appointed time, we will begin the first Expert Committee on High-Ranking Hunter Activities and Social Responsibility."

After the secretariat introduced the attendees, confirmed the materials, and explained the scope of disclosure for the proceedings, the proceedings were handed over to the chair.

The first agenda item was the background that had led to considering a new system.

The materials presented by the secretariat listed solo clearing of high-difficulty dungeons, prolonged loss of contact, acquisition of rare materials that could significantly impact existing distribution volumes, overseas activities, and the emergence of hunters with outstanding abilities not anticipated under existing systems.

It was a document carefully created to avoid using proper nouns.

Even so, it had not succeeded in hiding who most of it was written about.

"Based on the above, we believe it is necessary to consider a new framework for hunters with abilities above a certain level, including keeping track of their activity status, regular contact during long-term clearing, information sharing regarding overseas activities, and cooperation regarding the distribution of rare materials."

When the explanation ended, the chair looked around at the committee members.

"Thank you. First, I would like to hear your opinions on the necessity of establishing a system itself."

The first to speak was a committee member specializing in crisis management.

"I believe a certain framework is necessary. From a crisis management perspective, a state in which the whereabouts and activity status of a hunter with extremely high abilities cannot be grasped at all is not desirable. Especially in the event of a large-scale stampede, a communication system that allows for quickly requesting cooperation would be necessary."

Several committee members nodded. From the perspective of those entrusted with public safety, it was a natural opinion.

But at those words, a committee member specializing in law raised a hand.

"May I confirm one point? What you just described—is that a system for 'requesting' cooperation? Or a system for 'obligating' cooperation?"

The gazes of the conference room gathered.

"At this stage, I believe that is also a point to be considered."

"Then we need to separate that first. Requesting and obligating have completely different meanings."

The legal scholar turned a page of the documents.

"For example, if a large-scale stampede occurs, we want Magami-shi to cooperate. I have no objection to that itself. I would ask him myself. However, 'Please help us' and 'You have a responsibility to help' are not the same thing."

For the first time in this meeting, the name Magami Koichiro was spoken. No one reprimanded it. Rather, the fact that proper nouns had been avoided until then was more unnatural.

"There is also the view that having abilities gives rise to a social responsibility commensurate with them, isn't there?"

Another committee member spoke.

"Of course, that view exists."

The legal scholar did not deny it either.

"That is precisely why it is necessary to clarify where that responsibility arises from. Magami-shi is not a public servant. He is not a Self-Defense Force officer or a firefighter. Nor was his ability granted to him through a contract with the state."

There, he turned his gaze to the JHA attendee.

"The JHA did not cultivate him either, correct?"

"...No."

The answer was short.

In the first place, Koichiro had entered Rokko Mountain Dungeon before the current hunter system was in place, and had spent eight years there. The current qualification system had merely incorporated him into the existing framework after his return.

"If that is the case, then regarding abilities that the individual acquired without state involvement, if the state can demand their use simply because the abilities are great—"

The legal scholar paused once.

"Is that the individual's responsibility? Or is it the state's need?"

No answer came immediately.

This time, the crisis management committee member spoke.

"However, we need to consider extreme cases as well. A situation where the lives of tens of thousands, possibly more, are in danger, and no one other than Magami-shi can handle it. Even in such a situation, should it be left entirely to the individual's free will?"

"I believe that is an important question."

The legal scholar nodded.

"Then, in that case, would the state create a system that can order a private individual to perform an act involving risk to life?"

"That far—"

"But if he cannot refuse, then in the end, that is what it comes to."

The discussion stopped there for a moment.

There is someone who can do it.

Only that person can do it.

If that person acts, many lives might be saved.

So he should act.

Morally, it is easy to understand. But the moment the state replaces that with a legal obligation it can enforce, a different problem arises.

"We need to be careful not to create a system where the higher one's abilities, the less freedom one is recognized to have as a private individual."

The chair organized the discussion, and the secretariat took notes.

The next point was punitive measures including qualification suspension.

If obligations such as reporting and contact were to be established, measures for violations would be necessary.

The secretariat's draft listed guidance, recommendations, temporary activity restrictions, and ultimately qualification suspension as examples.

"I'd like to confirm something."

The former hunter committee member spoke while looking at the documents.

"If his qualifications are suspended, what would trouble Magami-shi?"

"His activities as a hunter would be restricted."

"I understand that. I mean not in terms of the system, but what would trouble him personally."

The secretariat side faltered slightly.

"In addition to being unable to enter dungeons, the sale of materials would also—"

"Then what if he himself says, 'Understood. I won't do anything for a while'?"

The conference room fell silent.

"In that case... his clearing activities would also stop."

"Who would be troubled?"

This time, no answer came immediately.

"Society, I suppose."

The economics committee member answered.

"Right."

The former hunter nodded.

"Then does that function as a punishment for Magami-shi? If he doesn't need the qualifications himself, it feels like the state side would just be handing him a reason to stop his activities."

The word 'qualification suspension' began to carry a different meaning.

For an ordinary hunter, it would be a serious disciplinary measure. But the qualification itself was not what produced his abilities. And no one in the meeting had an accurate answer as to how much he actually needed those qualifications.

The discussion moved to rare materials.

"From an industrial policy perspective, I believe it is necessary to seek a certain degree of cooperation."

The industry committee member spoke.

"Among the materials Magami-shi can obtain are some that would have a major impact on existing industries. A state in which supply fluctuates greatly based on a single individual's judgment cannot be ignored from the perspective of economic security either."

"I understand that point."

The legal scholar answered.

"However, that also contains the same problem as before. Whose property are those materials?"

"In principle, they belong to the hunter who obtained them."

The JHA official answered.

"Then what is the basis for the state to demand supply?"

"Public interest, or necessity from an economic security standpoint—"

"In other words, the state needs them."

"There is that aspect."

"If so, isn't it dangerous to process that with only the words 'social responsibility'?"

The dungeon researcher also cut in.

"I've been slightly concerned about this from earlier. If a stampede occurs, we want him to handle it. We want him to clear high-difficulty dungeons. We want him to supply rare materials too. If he goes overseas, we want him to inform us. Each individual request has rationality."

He closed his documents.

"But all of them are things society or the state want Magami-shi to do."

No one denied it.

"If you collectively call that 'Magami-shi's social responsibility,' doesn't the subject of the conversation get swapped out?"

In the conference room, only the sound of pages turning echoed.

An hour and a half since the discussion began. The documents placed before the attendees were already filled with many annotations.

Keeping track of activity status.

Regular contact.

Emergency cooperation.

Overseas activities.

Rare materials.

Qualification suspension.

Each, viewed individually, had reason for the state to consider it. The problem was how far these could be imposed on a private individual based solely on the single point of 'possessing outstanding abilities.'

"I think we should return to the fundamentals for a moment."

The chair spoke.

"In today's discussion, many opinions have been raised about what we want Magami-shi to do."

The committee members raised their faces.

"Then, conversely, how much do we know about Magami-shi's own intentions?"

Gazes gathered on the secretariat.

"Has there been a formal hearing of his opinions regarding the system draft?"

"At this stage, we have not conducted one."

"How much does he need his JHA qualifications?"

"We do not have an accurate grasp of that."

"Regarding his intention to continue operating within Japan in the future?"

"...That also has not been formally confirmed."

A short silence fell.

The documents contained pages upon pages of items being requested of Magami Koichiro.

But there was no section written about what Magami Koichiro wanted.

"...Isn't the order reversed?"

The former hunter committee member muttered.

The chair gazed at the documents for a while, then nodded quietly.

"Perhaps so."

And he turned back to the secretariat.

"Let's reorganize the points of discussion by the next meeting. 'What do we want from high-ranking hunters' alone is insufficient."

He paused once.

"What can the state request of a high-ranking hunter who is a private individual? And what can the state not request? Please add this perspective."

"Understood."

"Regarding qualification suspension as well, reconsider not only its effectiveness but whether it is consistent with the purpose of the system. Regarding overseas activities, organize nationality, domestic qualifications, and organizational affiliation separately."

The secretariat wrote down one after another.

"Also."

Finally, the legal scholar raised a hand.

"I would like you to also organize the term 'social responsibility.'"

"Please give your reason."

"We need you to cooperate, so please do. If that is the case, it is a request."

It was a calm voice.

"If it is a responsibility that the individual cannot refuse, then it must be clarified where that responsibility arises from and how far it extends."

And he lowered his eyes to the meeting name written on the cover of the documents.

"The moral expectation of 'You can do it, so you should' and the legal obligation the state imposes on a private individual are different things. Creating a system while leaving that boundary ambiguous is something we should avoid."

The first meeting ended more than ten minutes past schedule.

No conclusion was reached.

Instead, the points the secretariat needed to organize by the next meeting had increased significantly.

What can the state request of a private individual with outstanding abilities?

If those abilities were not granted by the state, where does social responsibility arise from?

Should someone with the ability to save many lives be granted the freedom to do nothing?

Qualification suspension—a sanction against whom?

And above all, what does the person himself want?

Without formally placing the name Magami Koichiro on the agenda, it was a meeting that had discussed Magami Koichiro for nearly two hours.

Even so, the discussion had meaning.

At the very least, they had finally begun to arrive at the question of—

"What can the state be permitted to request of Magami Koichiro?"

—from the question of—

"What should Magami Koichiro be made to do?"

However, by that time.

Another organization had already posed a completely different question to him.

—What do you wish for?

The sand in the hourglass would not wait for the committee's conclusion.