chapter02 · 057-ep57
Chapter 2, Episode 57: The Second Expert Committee Meeting
The second expert committee meeting was held approximately two months after the first.
At the previous meeting, no conclusion had been reached.
Instead, many issues had been taken home. What legal basis could be established for the social responsibility demanded of high-ranking hunters? To what extent could the state request cooperation in emergencies? Did measures such as qualification suspension even have effectiveness? When operating overseas, how should Japanese nationality, domestic qualifications, and organizational affiliation be organized? And when the state or society needed rare materials obtained from high-ranking dungeons, how could that necessity be balanced with individual rights?
Two months was a short time to answer all of these.
But it was also enough time to investigate.
During that period, while the secretariat proceeded with the legal organization of each point, it also conducted hearings with active hunters through the JHA. The targets were high-ranking hunters, mainly S-rank parties in Japan.
What was asked of them was not an evaluation of Magami Koichiro as an individual.
In the future hunter system, how should cooperation requests and activity obligations by the state be considered? It was the opinions of those on the front lines themselves.
"Now then, we will begin the second meeting. First, regarding each point carried over from the previous meeting, we will hear from the secretariat and the responsible experts."
The first topic taken up was social responsibility.
"Based on the previous discussion, we have organized the systems under current law that can request a private individual to cooperate in acts involving danger."
The documents placed before the legal scholar were clearly thicker than at the first meeting.
"To state the conclusion, we believe it is difficult to impose a continuous activity obligation based solely on the fact of 'possessing high abilities.'"
"Even in emergencies?"
"That needs to be considered separately."
The legal scholar turned a page.
"A system that requests temporary cooperation when there is an imminent danger to life and a system that obligates specific activities during normal times are different in nature. I am not saying there is no room for consideration regarding the former."
"So in an emergency, you can order him?"
"I am not saying that far."
It was returned immediately.
"Who certifies the state of emergency? What scale of damage is covered? How much danger to the individual is tolerated? Are penalties established for refusal? At the very least, it is difficult to impose a comprehensive obligation with only the words 'social responsibility' without defining those."
"In other words, normal-time activity obligations and emergency cooperation should be considered separately."
"That would be more appropriate."
The chair wrote in the documents at hand.
"Then, please continue organizing on that premise. Next, regarding qualification suspension measures."
The secretariat staff opened the documents.
"If domestic hunter qualifications are suspended, entry into dungeons under JHA management, official transactions of materials, and the use of various support provided by the JHA are restricted."
"For an ordinary hunter, that would be a considerable disadvantage."
"Yes. However, when using qualification suspension as a sanction or deterrent measure, it is premised on the subject needing the qualification."
"And in Magami-shi's case?"
"We cannot judge."
It was a short answer.
"At least, since the complete conquest of Sakaihigashi Dungeon, there is no record of Magami-shi newly entering a domestic dungeon."
"The period?"
"It has been nearly three months."
Several people raised their faces.
"It's right after the conquest. Isn't he just resting?"
"That is possible."
"He was diving for nearly half a year, after all."
"Yes."
If so, resting for a few months was not unnatural.
"Income?"
"We have also not confirmed how much income from activities through the JHA he actually needs."
The former hunter committee member crossed his arms.
"In the end, it's the same as last time. We don't know whether suspending his qualifications would trouble him, or whether him stopping his activities would trouble society."
"That is the current assessment."
Next, the report moved to overseas activities.
"Regarding overseas activities, it is necessary to consider four points separately: nationality, domestic hunter qualifications, organizational affiliation, and location of activity."
The official presented the documents.
"It is difficult to place all hunter activities conducted overseas under the management of the domestic qualification system simply because one holds Japanese nationality. Additionally, overseas activities give rise to relationships with local laws and international hunter-related systems."
"Can we obligate prior reporting?"
"Establishing it as a system itself can be considered. However, on what basis, targeting whom, and what measures would be taken for violations—these require separate organization."
"Suspending domestic qualifications would work."
"It would be effective if the domestic qualification is necessary for overseas activity."
"...And if it is not necessary?"
"Suspension of domestic qualifications cannot stop overseas activity itself."
Holding nationality. Holding domestic qualifications. Belonging to a domestic organization. And operating within Japan.
These were not necessarily the same. On that point, the organization was clearer than at the first meeting.
Next, the report moved to the economic field.
"Regarding rare materials, we conducted hearings with industry."
The economics committee member opened the documents.
"Among materials obtained from high-ranking dungeons, there are some that are difficult to substitute or for which no substitute currently exists. If stable supply becomes possible, they could hold extremely high value in multiple industrial fields."
"Also important for economic security?"
"Naturally, that should be considered. However—"
The committee member paused there.
"The fact that the state or industry needs them and the fact that the individual who owns them incurs a supply obligation are separate issues."
"Public interest?"
"Just because public interest is high, one cannot immediately deny an individual's ownership. First, ordinary economic means such as purchasing, priority contracts, and stockpiling systems should be considered."
"In other words, if you need it, buy it."
"Put simply, yes."
Small laughter arose.
But it quickly faded.
"Next, we will report on the hearings with active hunters."
The JHA staff member opened the documents.
"Following the previous meeting, we sought opinions mainly from domestic S-rank parties regarding cooperation with the state, activity obligations, and the qualification system."
"What were the results?"
"Opinions are divided. Regarding cooperation in national crises, there was generally understanding. However, regarding the obligation of activities, cautious opinions stood out."
The staff member turned a page.
"In particular, many voices called for clear standards regarding danger assessment, the right to refuse missions, and compensation for injury or death."
"So they are not refusing cooperation itself?"
"Yes. However, it is the opinion that cooperation and coercion are separate issues."
The former hunter committee member nodded slightly.
"As someone who knows the field, that is a natural reaction."
"Also, regarding qualification suspension, while it is understandable as a disciplinary measure for violations of rules under the qualification system, there was notable opposition to using it as a sanction for refusing a cooperation request."
The staff member turned a page.
"On the other hand, some opinions called for institutionalizing a certain obligation to mobilize in national crises. However, even in that case, there was general agreement that compensation and clarification of mission scope would be necessary."
The chair looked at the documents.
"In other words, they are not denying the system itself. But its operation requires appropriate conditions."
"That is how we have organized it."
A brief silence fell over the conference room.
◇
"There is one more point—a proposal examined from a different direction than before."
The committee member specializing in administrative systems opened new documents.
"If the difficulty in legal organization arises from trying to impose public duties on a private individual, then perhaps a method of granting a public status based on the individual's consent could be considered."
"Appoint him as a public servant?"
"That is one proposal."
The air in the room changed slightly.
"For example, a method of having him affiliated with the Self-Defense Forces and appointing him as a specially appointed national public servant. Of course, I do not think the existing Self-Defense Force officer system can be applied as is. However, regarding the rights and obligations with the state, it becomes clearer than seeking social responsibility while remaining a private individual."
"Would dungeon clearing be his duty?"
"Not only clearing. Responses to large-scale stampedes, non-biological disasters difficult for conventional forces to handle, and other national emergencies can also be envisioned."
The legal expert checked the documents.
"Logically, some of the earlier problems can be resolved."
"Yes. At the very least, it is not 'you bear an obligation because you have ability,' but rather the individual consents to acquire a public status and bears certain duties based on that status."
"However, placing him under the same command structure as ordinary Self-Defense Force officers would be impossible."
"That point would need new organization. Rank, command structure, scope of missions, conditions under which missions can be refused, compensation, overseas activities, damage compensation—special provisions would need to be established."
The former hunter committee member smiled wryly while looking at the documents.
"This is almost a dedicated system."
"As a result, that possibility exists."
"Then doesn't it end up being a system just for Magami-shi?"
"The fact that there is currently only one qualifying person and limiting the system itself to a specific individual are separate. There is no need to deny the possibility that a hunter with equivalent abilities will appear in the future."
"That's assuming he accepts it, right?"
"Of course. He cannot be forcibly appointed."
"Then what benefit would there be for Magami-shi?"
With that question, another silence arose.
"Guaranteed status as a national public servant."
"Does he need it?"
"Stable compensation."
"Is there information that he is struggling financially?"
"None."
"Equipment and activity support."
"He is someone who reaches floor 500 on his own."
"Government support for overseas activities and coordination with relevant countries."
"Does he want that?"
No answer came.
The former hunter committee member leaned back in his chair.
"In the end, it comes back to that."
"What he himself wants."
"Yes."
The administrative systems committee member nodded too.
"As a system, it can be an option. However, if he has no intention of accepting it, it cannot be established."
The chair wrote in the documents.
"Then, regarding the granting of public status, we will continue examining it as one option. We will assume institutional design premised on his consent and benefits to him."
"May I say one thing?"
There, the legal expert who had also attended the previous meeting raised a hand.
"This relates to what we just discussed, but I believe at the previous meeting, an opinion was raised that the very act of discussing a system without confirming the individual's intentions was problematic."
"Yes."
"I am aware that hearings with active hunters were conducted. However, in this discussion, the applicability of the system to Magami-shi individually is also being examined."
The legal expert paused once.
"Has a hearing with Magami-shi himself been conducted?"
The secretariat exchanged glances slightly.
"At present, it has not yet been carried out."
"It has been two months since the last meeting, correct?"
"Yes."
"In today's report as well, there are many items that cannot be judged because they have not been confirmed with him. Does he need the qualification? Does he intend to continue operating domestically? Does he intend to operate overseas? How does he intend to handle materials? And now, does he intend to accept a public status?"
No one denied it.
"Then, why don't we ask him directly?"
"Until now, we have prioritized organizing the institutional aspects. Regarding contact with him, we have envisioned doing so through the JHA."
"If it's the JHA, you can reach him, correct?"
Gazes gathered on the JHA side.
One of them looked at Todo.
"Osaka Branch Chief Todo knows his phone number."
"Me?"
Todo raised his face.
"Would it be possible to contact him once from this venue?"
"By phone, yes."
"Please do."
"I don't mind."
Todo took out his smartphone from his pocket.
He opened his contacts and selected the registered number. He called it.
Several seconds later.
"The number you have dialed is either powered off or—"
The automated voice began, and Todo ended the call.
"No good."
"...It's turned off?"
"Seems so."
"Is it like this normally?"
"Basically, it doesn't connect."
At the answer returned so casually, several people looked at Todo.
"Then how do you normally contact him?"
"I call him."
"...But it doesn't connect, right?"
"Yes."
"Then you can't contact him?"
"If I call, he'll call back when he notices."
"You just have to wait for the call back?"
"Yes."
Todo placed the smartphone on the desk.
"When I contact him, that's basically all."
For a while, no one opened their mouth.
"Does the JHA headquarters have another means of contact?"
"No."
The JHA staff member answered.
"The only contact means we have that connects directly to him is that number."
"Until now as well?"
"Yes."
Until now, that had not been a major problem.
Magami Koichiro is not a JHA employee. He does not commute at set times, nor does he have an obligation to constantly respond to JHA contacts. If necessary, they call, and if he notices, he calls back.
That was the extent of the relationship.
But when it became necessary to confirm his intentions before proceeding, that fact began to carry a different meaning.
"How long does a call back take?"
"I don't know."
"Could be the same day?"
"It might."
"Could be days later?"
"That's possible."
"Could it take even longer?"
"Probably."
Todo answered calmly.
The legal expert lowered his eyes to the documents before him.
Legal basis for social responsibility.
Emergency cooperation requests.
Qualification suspension measures.
Overseas activities.
Rare materials.
Granting of public status.
Two months had been spent, and far more had been investigated than at the first meeting.
What was known had increased. What could be done and what could not.
The boundary was gradually becoming visible.
Yet many problems ultimately returned to the same place.
What does he himself think?
"...Then, once Magami-shi calls back, please coordinate regarding the hearing of his opinions."
"Understood."
The chair said so and wrote in the documents.
Then moved to the next agenda item.
At this point, no one was yet thinking seriously about it.
Magami Koichiro was not originally an easy person to contact.
They had called.
The power was off.
Then they just had to wait for a call back.
Just like before.
However, only Todo had a premonition.
That this phone number would soon no longer be used...
He had such a feeling.