chapter03 · 074-sidestory04
Side Story Act.4: Broadcasting Ethics Verification Committee — What Was Protected —
Broadcasting Ethics & Program Improvement Organization.
Commonly known as BPO.
It is a third-party organization established to protect freedom of expression in broadcasting while defending the rights of viewers and promoting the improvement of broadcasting ethics. One day, opinions from viewers began pouring into its secretariat in rapid succession.
The cause was a series of reports on suspicion of illegal departure.
Magami Koichiro.
A young man who lost social credibility nine years ago due to a false accusation of groping and later returned from Rokko Mountain Dungeon after eight years. Regarding him, multiple TV stations reported suspicion of illegal departure based on the fact that no legitimate departure record could be confirmed.
However, through the WHA's explanation, it became clear that he had used a special travel system. The travel itself had been through proper procedures.
Even so, the suspicion that had been reported did not disappear.
At least, not from viewers' memories.
◇ ◇ ◇
"...It's increased again this week."
A secretariat staff member placed the compiled data on the desk. Opinions sent in by viewers.
The majority were criticisms of the reporting regarding Magami Koichiro.
"Shouldn't they have confirmed the system before reporting something that made him look like a criminal?"
"They're doing the same thing again to someone who was a victim of a false accusation eight years ago."
"Is it acceptable to report anything as long as you attach the word 'suspicion'?"
"The correction broadcast was too small."
The staff member in charge's eyes stopped on the last opinion.
"...They did issue corrections, right?"
"Response differs by station, but we have confirmed follow-up reports that it was legitimate travel."
"Then what's the problem?"
The supervisor thought for a while before answering.
"Whether the initial report and the subsequent correction were received with the same weight by viewers, I suppose."
The staff member silently reviewed the documents.
When the suspicion was reported, there were large headlines and expert commentary attached.
On the other hand, some programs ended the correction with only a brief explanation.
"...I'll report this to the committee."
"Yes. Please also gather the broadcast footage and each station's explanation."
◇ ◇ ◇
Broadcasting Ethics Verification Committee.
The ten committee members, including the chair, were experts with different specialties—law, journalism, media studies, and video production. One of the agenda items for that day was the reporting regarding Magami Koichiro.
"First, let us hear from the secretariat."
At the chair's words, the person in charge stood up.
"At multiple broadcasters, reporting was conducted that cast doubt on the legality of Magami Koichiro-shi's overseas travel. Subsequently, through the WHA's explanation, it was confirmed that the travel was based on a legitimate system."
"How did each station respond?"
"Corrections or supplementary explanations have been made. However, there are differences in content and treatment."
A committee member who was a lawyer raised a hand.
"In the first place, was confirmation of the system carried out at the stage of reporting the suspicion?"
"According to the written explanations submitted, they placed importance on the fact that no ordinary departure record could be confirmed."
"You haven't answered the question. I am asking whether they confirmed the existence of the special travel system."
The secretariat member turned the pages of the documents.
"...There is no record stating that they confirmed it."
Another committee member spoke.
"Then we need to verify the appropriateness of the reporting in detail."
The chair nodded.
"I propose that we enter formal deliberations on this matter."
There were no objections.
Thus, the Broadcasting Ethics Verification Committee decided to enter deliberations.
◇ ◇ ◇
As the deliberations progressed, explanations from each station were gathered.
One station argued that it was a matter of high public interest.
Another explained that they had not asserted it was an illegal departure.
Yet another responded that they had presented appropriate questions based on the information available at the time.
One of the committee members placed the documents on the desk.
"Every station is saying the same thing."
"What is?"
"They didn't assert it. They merely presented suspicion. There was public interest."
"From the perspective of freedom of the press, there are parts that can be understood."
The acting chair answered.
"I am not denying that point. However, we should examine whether the basis for the suspicion was insufficient."
There, a committee member specializing in journalism studies spoke.
"Shouldn't we also confirm the documents regarding the case from eight years ago?"
The conference room fell silent.
"Isn't that a separate matter from this reporting?"
"It is a separate matter. However, the subject of the reporting is the same. Reporting that cast suspicion of a crime on a person who had previously been a victim of a false accusation. Can we verify only the interview procedures without considering those circumstances?"
"Are you saying we should add the reporting from eight years ago itself to the scope of this deliberation?"
"I am not saying that far. I am saying that it cannot be said to be unrelated when considering the impact caused by this reporting."
The chair crossed his arms.
"...There is a concern that the points of discussion will expand too much."
Another committee member nodded.
"If we start dealing with past reporting, there is a possibility that this deliberation will not converge."
"But—"
"The subject of this deliberation is, at most, the reporting regarding the overseas travel. Shouldn't we narrow it to the interview process and the nature of the corrections?"
Cautious opinions continued. No one said that the false accusation case from eight years ago was a trivial matter.
They simply differed on how much of it should be included in this deliberation.
And the center of the discussion gradually shifted to the confirmation procedures at the time of reporting and the nature of correction broadcasts.
◇ ◇ ◇
Some time after that.
The draft of the committee's decision was presented.
The content pointed out the possibility that there were insufficient points in each broadcaster's confirmation procedures, while taking into consideration that the reporting had not asserted illegality and that subsequent corrections and supplementary explanations had been made. The conclusion settled on requesting that news organizations conduct more cautious corroborating interviews and appropriate correction responses going forward.
"...Is this the end?"
The lawyer committee member asked.
"Is there a problem?"
"In this draft, there is almost no verification of why multiple stations reported suspicion about the same person without conducting sufficient confirmation."
"It does mention the insufficiency of confirmation procedures."
"It only mentions it."
The committee member pointed to a passage in the draft with his finger.
"'Further improvement is desired.' With this, won't viewers fail to understand what happened in this reporting?"
"The committee is not an organization that punishes news organizations."
"I am not seeking punishment. I am seeking verification."
The chair spoke.
"I understand your concern. However, we must also avoid an excessive chilling effect on freedom of the press."
"Do freedom of the press and verifying the content of reporting conflict?"
No one answered immediately.
In the end, some amendments were made to the draft.
However, the direction of the conclusion did not change.
◇ ◇ ◇
The day of the public announcement of the committee's decision.
A press conference was held.
The chair read out the opinion in a calm voice.
The importance of confirmation in interviews.
The social impact of suspicion reporting.
Appropriate implementation of corrections and supplementary explanations.
And expectations for future improvement from each broadcaster.
When the Q&A session began, one reporter raised a hand.
"The subject of this reporting has previously been a victim of a false accusation case. How did the committee evaluate that point?"
"We are aware of the past case. However, this deliberation concerns reporting on overseas travel."
"Then, regarding the fact that suspicion of a crime was once again directed at a person who had previously been a victim of a false accusation?"
"The opinion we have published is the result of a comprehensive judgment regarding the individual reporting content."
The reporter asked once more.
"Was it judged that there was a problem in terms of broadcasting ethics in this reporting?"
"We believe there were points where improvement is desired regarding confirmation procedures."
"Does that mean there was a problem in terms of broadcasting ethics?"
The chair paused for a moment.
"The committee's evaluation is as stated in the published opinion."
The press conference ended without further major disruption.
At least, in that venue.
◇ ◇ ◇
The next morning.
At the BPO secretariat, the phones kept ringing.
"...Again?"
"Yes. Regarding yesterday's committee decision."
Opinions from viewers were increasing at a pace exceeding those regarding the earlier reporting.
"In the end, was there a problem or wasn't there? I can't tell."
"If all they're doing is requesting prevention of recurrence, what was the point of entering deliberations?"
"Aren't they just accepting the explanations of the stations that reported the suspicion?"
"The position of the person who was harmed is not being considered at all."
Online as well, discussion was spreading.
[BPO, what exactly did you verify in the end?] [There's a false accusation from eight years ago, and they're avoiding it?] [Freedom of the press is important. But corroborating interviews are important too.] [If corrections make everything forgivable, then whoever reports big first wins.] [What is a third-party organization independent from, anyway?]
Some of the criticism misunderstood the BPO system.
The BPO has no authority to impose penalties on broadcasters.
Nor can it produce conclusions that every viewer desires.
But this criticism was not merely about such institutional limitations. Sufficient explanation had not been given regarding the issues that were supposed to have been deliberated.
That distrust was spreading.
◇ ◇ ◇
"...This exceeds expectations."
The secretary-general gazed at the latest compiled data.
The chair's expression had also clouded.
"Perhaps the content of the opinion is not being communicated sufficiently."
"Should we issue an additional explanation?"
"First, let us organize the situation."
At that moment, another staff member entered the conference room.
"Excuse me. I have a report regarding movements in the Diet."
"The Diet?"
"Multiple lawmakers are taking issue with this committee decision. There appear to be opinions that the effectiveness of self-regulation regarding broadcasting ethics should be taken up in the Diet."
"...Does that mean questions to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications?"
"It's not only that."
The staff member held out a document.
"There are also voices saying that BPO officials and representatives of broadcasters should be asked to explain directly."
The chair received the document.
It recorded movements toward considering requesting reference persons to appear before a Diet committee.
"...It hasn't been decided yet, has it."
"Yes. At present, it is at the consideration stage."
The secretary-general let out a small breath.
"However, to think it would spread this far..."
No one answered.
◇ ◇ ◇
Several days later.
In the Diet, discussion had begun regarding broadcast administration and the nature of self-regulation.
One lawmaker made this statement in committee.
"I am not telling the BPO to produce a specific conclusion."
The lawmaker held up the documents in his hand.
"I also understand that a voluntary verification system is necessary to protect freedom of broadcasting."
And then continued.
"However, when that system loses the trust of society, who, and how, is supposed to restore that trust?"
The chamber fell silent.
"What is being questioned here is not merely whether the judgment was strict or lenient."
"Why did they reach that judgment?"
"What did they investigate, and what did they not investigate?"
"Was there enough specificity in the explanation for the public to be convinced?"
The lawmaker concluded.
"If an organization that supports the self-cleansing function of broadcasters cannot explain its own judgment, trust in the very mechanism of voluntary broadcasting regulation will waver."
In the committee, coordination proceeded toward inviting those involved as reference persons to hear their opinions.
◇ ◇ ◇
That evening.
In the BPO conference room, the chair and several involved parties faced each other.
"...Did we make the wrong judgment?"
At the chair's question, no one answered immediately.
Eventually, that lawyer committee member spoke.
"Isn't it necessary to verify that once more?"
"The committee decision?"
"Yes."
The committee member gazed at the documents on the desk.
"We were in a position to ask whether broadcasters could verify their own reporting."
And continued quietly.
"Then what about ourselves?"
Silence fell over the conference room.
A committee to answer that question had not yet been established.
◇ ◇ ◇
Magami Koichiro has issued no statement regarding this series of movements.
Nor has the WHA made any additional protest.
With the person concerned remaining silent, the judgment of news organizations was questioned, and the judgment of the organization that verified that judgment was being questioned further. No one ordered it.
No one sought revenge.
Each made judgments under their own responsibility.
And now, it was simply their turn to explain those judgments.