chapter04 · 105-sidestory15

Side Story Act.15: Who Decides?

A certain rented conference room in Nagoya.

Ten men and women were seated around a long table. Seven operating mainly in Tokyo and three based in Kansai. All were active hunters certified as S-rank within Japan. Some knew each other from joint clearing operations, while others only knew names and achievements. But this was the first time all ten had gathered in one place.

The meeting didn't start with stiff formalities right away.

Recent clearing conditions, information received from overseas acquaintances, characteristics of newly discovered non-biological entities—conversation between people in the same profession continued for a while. The international joint research on the five types of anomalous minerals announced the other day was also touched upon briefly.

"If research progresses, our equipment might change too."

"I'm looking forward to it, but practical application is probably still a long way off."

Samples had already been delivered to research institutions in various countries, and analysis had apparently begun.

However, it would still take considerable time before those results were reflected in actual equipment. The conversation naturally returned to the clearing matters at hand.

Eventually, the man in his fifties from the Tokyo side checked his watch.

"Well then, shall we get to the main topic?"

The casual conversation settled, and the gazes of all ten gathered.

◇

The catalyst for this gathering was the opinion hearing conducted by the JHA with active high-ranking hunters. After the first expert committee meeting, questionnaires regarding the system had arrived at their doorsteps. Cooperation in national crises, the merits of activity obligations, qualification suspension, compensation for engaging in dangerous missions.

All ten had responded in writing, but they didn't know what each other had written. So they decided to first confirm each other's responses. The man from Tokyo was in favor of cooperation in national emergencies. However, he believed clear criteria were needed for who holds the authority to order deployment and who judges the danger level of missions.

The woman from Kansai emphasized compensation for injury or death. If one is going to risk their life to fight, guarantees are necessary not only for the individual but also for their family. If activity obligations were to be established, she could not accept them with ambiguous conditions. Another man strongly opposed using qualification suspension as a penalty for refusing cooperation.

"Qualifications are for operating as a hunter, right? Using them as a tool to make people obey is wrong, I think."

"But a system to suspend qualifications for serious rule violations is necessary, isn't it?"

"That's true. What I'm talking about is the case of refusing a mobilization request."

The ten opinions were not necessarily in agreement. Some believed they should actively cooperate in national crises, while others believed individual judgment should be respected.

Even so, they largely shared the view that if activity obligations were to be established, the danger assessment, conditions for refusal, and scope of compensation should be clarified.

"...Listening to everyone like this, you've all written quite a lot of detail."

The man from Tokyo said with admiration.

"Of course. It's a matter that concerns us."

"I even attached a separate sheet because the answer space wasn't enough."

Several people laughed at those words. The written opinion hearing was by no means meaningless.

It had become an opportunity to organize each person's thoughts and convey them to the government side. But talking directly like this revealed that there were many circumstances that could not be fully explained through the questionnaire alone.

For example, the case of being requested for emergency mobilization while in the middle of clearing a dungeon. Who handles, and how, the time and funds lost by interrupting the clearing, and the impact on party members accompanying them?

Or the case where the administrative side's assessment of danger at the destination conflicts with the on-site hunter's judgment. Which takes priority? Questions they hadn't noticed when responding in writing emerged one after another.

"...Well, once you start talking about this, there's no end to it."

The man in his fifties smiled wryly.

"But if we're actually going to create a system, these are issues we can't avoid."

No one argued against those words.

◇

"By the way, there's one thing I've been curious about."

The man in his forties from the Tokyo side, who had been listening until then, spoke up.

"In the first place, what kind of people are the JHA higher-ups who keep telling us all these things?"

Several people raised their faces.

"I know the branch staff. They're always taking care of us. But when it comes to the big shots at headquarters, there are quite a few whose names I don't even know, aren't there?"

Now that he mentioned it, that was true. The people they dealt with on a daily basis were the branch staff. Entry procedures, confirmation of clearing records, assessment of materials, provision of information on non-biological entities.

Their activities were supported by the work of those staff members. But regarding the upper management that decided the JHA's overall policies, they had barely ever thought about them.

"I looked into that a bit, actually."

The woman from Kansai took out her terminal.

On the monitor by the wall, an organizational chart of the JHA and a compilation of executive backgrounds were displayed.

It was a compilation of publicly available rosters and personnel information, not special classified materials.

Broadly categorizing the backgrounds of the upper management, about half were former bureaucrats. Another quarter or so were people who had moved over from other administrative agencies or related organizations—so-called amakudari appointments. The remaining quarter or so were people with actual experience operating in dungeons, such as retired high-ranking hunters.

"...There are surprisingly few former hunters."

"Well, administrative specialists are probably necessary to run an organization."

"I understand that. But I'm curious how much they understand about what happens on the ground."

The JHA is a large organization responsible for domestic dungeon management and hunter qualification certification.

Law, budget, personnel allocation, coordination with various ministries. For such operations, people with abundant administrative experience are indispensable. Being a former bureaucrat itself was not the problem. But when activity obligations for hunters were being debated, as in this case, it became important to know whether the system was being examined with an understanding of the realities on the ground.

"Even so."

Another man said while looking at the organizational chart.

"The JHA isn't our employer, is it?"

"Of course not. We don't get salaries from them."

"Right. So they just manage qualifications—how much can they actually instruct us?"

That question didn't get an immediate answer. Following dungeon entry regulations and safety management instructions was understandable. There were naturally certain conditions for obtaining and renewing qualifications. But that and activity obligations to the state were separate matters. How far did the authority currently granted to the JHA under the existing system extend? If new obligations were to be established, what kind of legislation would be necessary? None of the ten accurately grasped the whole picture.

"...We surprisingly don't know a lot of things."

"Our job is clearing, normally. There's no time to read legal provisions."

"But this time, it seems like we should look into it."

It wasn't to criticize anyone. Regarding the system that concerns their own activities—what can be done and what cannot. First, they needed to know that boundary.

◇

"...Ah, this person is listed too."

The man from Kansai pointed to a corner of the screen. There was the name of JHA Osaka Branch Chief, Todo Tsuyoshi. In the background section, it was noted that he was a former B-rank hunter.

"Branch Chief Todo was a former hunter?"

One of the Tokyo group asked.

"Yeah. He made it up to B-rank."

"Huh. I thought he was purely an administrative person."

"No, he's definitely good at politics, though."

The Kansai man laughed. Todo had once operated in dungeons.

He hadn't reached A-rank, but after retiring, he built experience at the JHA and demonstrated skill in organizational coordination and negotiation.

"Even if you bring him an unreasonable request, he'll properly listen. He says what can't be done can't be done, but if it's something he can push through, he'll move on it."

"That's right. He clearly separates what he can do with his own authority from what needs to be confirmed with headquarters, and explains the difference."

To the three from Kansai, Todo was a trustworthy branch chief. When they consulted him about the opinion hearing, he explained what he could within his scope and offered to relay matters to headquarters if necessary. The seven from Tokyo also listened to that with interest.

"Come to think of it, the Magami matter was also handled by the Osaka Branch, right?"

The Tokyo man said, as if remembering.

"Both Rokko Mountain and Sakaihigashi are under Osaka's jurisdiction. Branch Chief Todo must have had a hard time too?"

"...Well, he seems to have been considerably busy."

The Kansai man answered. When Magami Koichiro returned from Rokko Mountain Dungeon, the Osaka Branch had been scrambling to respond—the Kansai hunters knew that much. The subsequent complete conquest of Sakaihigashi Dungeon would also have required various coordination at the branch. However, the three from Kansai had something that had been slightly bothering them for a while. Whenever the topic of Magami came up, Todo's response seemed subtly different from usual. As if he were choosing his words carefully, or as if he knew something but wouldn't speak more than necessary. Though, since he was the branch chief who had handled the return, it wasn't strange for him to be familiar with the circumstances.

"Todo-san has probably spoken directly with Magami, hasn't he?"

The Kansai woman said casually.

"Of course. He's the branch chief who handled the return."

The Tokyo man answered without seeming to pay it particular mind.

"...Yeah, that's right."

The woman said nothing further either.

Whether Todo and Magami were still in contact now, even the three from Kansai didn't know.

But somehow, something remained stuck. The seven from Tokyo, without noticing that small sense of unease, returned their gazes to the JHA organizational chart.

◇

By the time the conference room's usage time was nearing its end, what needed to be confirmed next had been organized among the ten. The laws and regulations defining the JHA's authority. The content of the system the government was examining.

And by what procedure the opinions submitted by active hunters were compiled and reflected in future discussions. The ten divided up what each could investigate and decided to share information at a later date. However, not everyone's opinions had aligned in this discussion. Some were proactive about cooperating with the state, while others emphasized freedom of activity.

There was no need to forcibly bridge that difference.

"Should we ask the others too?"

As they began preparing to leave, the man in his fifties spoke up.

There were still eight S-ranks in Japan they hadn't contacted. They might have also received opinion hearings from the JHA, and they might hold different views from the ten gathered here.

"Not everyone will have the same opinion."

"Of course. That's why we're asking."

Several people laughed at that reply. They exchanged contact information, confirmed they would continue sharing information, and the ten each headed home. In the Nagoya conference room, only the tidied chairs and the monitor with its power off remained.

On that screen, until a short while ago, the JHA organizational chart had been displayed. The system they had used without question. The rules they had followed as a matter of course. And the people who operated that mechanism.

Having submitted their opinions in writing as a catalyst, the ten had begun to turn their attention anew to the system surrounding their activities.

Who, and on what basis, decides matters concerning our activities?

To know the answer, first they would investigate.

That was all they had decided for now.