chapter04 · 108-sidestory16

Side Story Act.16: The Expanding Collar

A law office in Tokyo.

When the lawyer opened the door to the reception room, he involuntarily stopped in his tracks.

Besides his client, two other men were seated there. They were not strangers. Rather, there were few people who wouldn't recognize their faces. Of the mere eighteen S-rank hunters in Japan, three were gathered in a single reception room.

"Sorry, sensei. I brought two guys along on short notice."

His client raised one hand.

"No, it's fine. I just... didn't expect one-sixth of the country's S-ranks to be in my office."

The three laughed. The lawyer returned a smile, but his surprise was by no means exaggerated. They were the highest combat force supporting Japan's dungeon clearing. For three S-ranks who operated in different regions to all come for a legal consultation was extremely rare in itself.

Still, considering the nature of the request, he could understand why the client had brought two unrelated people. The current dungeon-related laws and the recently enacted law commonly known as the "Magami Law."

What his client had asked him to investigate were the problems those two carried.

With the appearance of Magami Koichiro, the first complete conqueror in history, situations that had never been anticipated were occurring one after another. By the time he was clearing the Hawaii Dungeon, the Magami Law had already passed the House of Representatives. It had afterward passed the House of Councillors as well and been enacted. Currently, in Hawaii, the announcement of new anomalous minerals and their provision to research institutions were attracting global attention.

Meanwhile, in Japan, preparations for enforcing the Magami Law were underway.

The lawyer had investigated the relevant laws and regulations, records of Diet deliberations, and public materials from the expert committee in advance, and had compiled a report. However, before beginning the report, one of the hunters present said there was something he wanted to confirm.

"Sensei. Our job is to hunt monsters."

The man continued in a calm tone.

"The drop items we get from defeating monsters are our reward. You could call it payment on success. Whether we get hurt or our equipment breaks, it's basically on us."

The lawyer nodded.

"There are people trying to snatch that payment-on-success away with all sorts of reasons—public interest, national security, whatever."

The man paused once there.

"On what grounds, who, and how far can they stick their hands into our rewards? I want that explained clearly."

It was a question shared by all three. They were not denying cooperation with the state. In fact, if dangerous monsters threatened people's lives, they would sometimes go to subjugate them themselves.

But that was different from having their professional rights restricted. After confirming their intent, the lawyer opened the first item of the report.

◇

The current dungeon-related laws had not sufficiently anticipated the complete conquest of dungeons. Entry qualifications, management of dangerous areas, monster subjugation, and transactions of obtained items—systems had been developed through years of operation. However, the question of how to handle a dungeon after complete conquest had remained largely untouched. Because until now, no one had ever achieved complete conquest.

The lawyer first explained that the JHA's management authority and ownership of the dungeon itself were different things. Just because the JHA managed entry did not mean it owned everything inside the dungeon. Similarly, just because a complete conqueror could use the management functions did not necessarily mean they automatically acquired legal ownership of the internal space. The current law lacked provisions clearly organizing that relationship.

Up to there, the three could understand.

But when the explanation reached the complete conqueror's management functions, one of them raised a question.

"Sensei. In the first place, those management functions can only be used by the complete conqueror, right?"

According to publicly available information, the management functions that became usable through complete conquest could only be handled by the conqueror themselves. Even if the state established by law that it was the managing entity of the dungeon, that fact would not change. Even if the state had management authority, if there was no one who could actually operate it, the management functions could not be moved.

The three immediately noticed that contradiction.

What Magami Koichiro had obtained through complete conquest was not an authority appointed and granted by the state. The dungeon's system itself granted that privilege to the person who fulfilled the condition of complete conquest.

"The state didn't make him conquer it, and it didn't escort him to the deepest part. He went himself, defeated the monsters himself, and finally obtained that privilege."

Those words carried the weight of someone who was a hunter himself. Even they, as S-ranks, had not reached complete conquest. Precisely because they knew how difficult it was, they felt a strong discomfort at others demanding as a matter of course the privilege granted only to the conqueror.

The lawyer also acknowledged that the privilege was not something granted by the state. However, legal ownership, management responsibility, and regulations accompanying the use of the privilege needed to be considered separately.

For example, if operating the management functions would create a serious danger to surrounding areas, there was rationality in regulations for protecting public safety. However, regulating dangerous operations and allowing the state to freely use the management functions were different things. A further problem was the handling of information obtained through complete conquest.

Details of the management functions, the internal structure, matters first revealed in the deepest part.

Regarding such information, there had been views calling for disclosure on grounds of national security or public interest. None of the three accepted this.

"...If they want to know so badly, they can go themselves."

One of the men laughed as if exasperated.

"The dungeon is right there. The entrance isn't closed. Go in, defeat the monsters, and reach the deepest part."

Another man nodded.

"We're S-rank too, but we haven't achieved complete conquest. So I'm not going to say hand over the privilege Magami obtained."

To them, it was an extremely simple logic. If you want something, go get it yourself. You cannot demand as a matter of course from someone who reached it something that exists in a place you could not reach. Of course, warning of disaster danger and revealing all knowledge obtained through clearing were different. The lawyer emphasized that point as well.

It was conceivable to establish a certain reporting obligation for information necessary for public safety. However, one could not demand all information while leaving unclear the purpose and scope of disclosure, protection of secrets, and necessary compensation. Moreover, even if information were disclosed, it would not enable others to use the complete conqueror's privilege.

Here the three arrived at an even more fundamental problem.

Even if the state decided to manage the dungeon, if the only one who could operate the management functions was Magami Koichiro, then ultimately his cooperation would be necessary. And if he refused, what would the state do? The lawyer explained that establishing legal management authority and ordering a private individual to operate it were separate issues. To obligate the latter, a legal basis commensurate with it would be necessary.

Even if management authority alone were established, the state could not acquire the complete conqueror's privilege itself. The client gazed at the report and muttered low.

"...So what the state wants isn't just the dungeon."

At those words, the lawyer opened the next set of materials.

There, the contents of the enacted Magami Law were organized.

◇

The Magami Law was not a law that recorded the name of the individual Magami Koichiro in its provisions.

It was structured as a system targeting those meeting certain conditions and defining the handling of abilities and resources important to the state. The problem lay in the interpretation of those conditions and the mechanism for designating subjects. The lawyer explained separately the parts finalized in the enacted provisions and the parts to be made concrete by future cabinet orders and operational standards. The content was by no means someone else's problem for the three. There was no one else with abilities like Magami Koichiro. At least, that was how it was currently viewed in Japan. However, if a broad standard such as "persons with clearing abilities important to the state" were used, it did not necessarily mean only complete conquerors would be targeted.

Depending on how the designation standards were set, S-rank hunters could also be included.

Furthermore, if that way of thinking spread, the debate could extend to A-rank and above. Of course, the administration could not arbitrarily expand the scope beyond what the law permitted.

The lawyer clearly distinguished that point.

However, if the law itself permitted broad designation authority, there remained room for the number of subjects to increase through its operation. What mattered was not what kind of people the law was intended to target.

It was how far the law's structure allowed people to be targeted.

"...Who the hell do they think we are?"

One of them muttered low.

What they were concerned about was not merely qualifications or status. Hunters operate under the JHA qualification system, but they are not employed by the JHA. Having qualifications and having an obligation to accept work ordered by the administration were different. The three had no objection to cooperating in a national emergency. If a large-scale stampede occurred and people's lives were threatened, they would probably fight themselves. However, cooperation in an emergency and being obligated to act continuously in normal times were legally different in nature.

Furthermore, if sanctions such as qualification suspension were imposed for refusing cooperation, the basis and rationality would be questioned. The qualification system was originally meant to manage the abilities and safety of those operating in dangerous dungeons.

Using it to force activity created another problem.

"...We're not the state's equipment."

No one laughed at the man's words. Then the topic returned to their rewards.

Until now, drop items had in principle been considered the property of the hunter who obtained them. Regulations could be imposed on the use or distribution of dangerous items.

But that did not mean ownership of obtained items naturally transferred to the state. Hunters took on danger themselves, defeated monsters, and brought back the results.

That was the fundamental mechanism by which it worked as a profession.

However, with the appearance of Magami Koichiro, rare materials and resources on a scale incomparable to before had begun to appear. The anomalous minerals currently announced by the WHA were one example.

There was ample possibility that they would become important resources related to industry, research, and national security. The lawyer explained that there was rational reason for the state to try to secure such resources. However, the method of securing necessary resources was not limited to restricting ownership.

Purchase at fair value, priority purchase contracts, stockpiling systems, contracts for provision to research institutions.

Various means could be considered.

"...In other words, if they need it, they should pay and buy it."

The client's words were met with a nod from the lawyer. Simply because something had public value did not mean the state could unconditionally take an individual's property.

That principle did not change even for materials obtained from dungeons.

◇

At the end of the report, the lawyer touched on the process of the Magami Law's enactment.

At the first expert committee meeting, the need to seek opinions from active high-ranking hunters had been pointed out. In fact, written opinion requests had been conducted through the JHA, and the three had responded as well.

That cooperation in national emergencies was understandable. However, that obligating normal-time activities should be approached cautiously. That criteria for danger assessment, right of refusal, and compensation needed to be clarified.

And opposition to using qualification suspension as a sanction for refusing cooperation. Those were opinions based on experience as active hunters. The problem lay in how much the submitted opinions had been reflected in the final law.

In the Diet deliberations as well, issues overlapping with their opinions had been taken up.

However, hearing opinions and adopting their content were different. In the enacted law, parts concerning designation of subjects, scope of activity obligations, and regulation of obtained items were left to future operation. The three were made to recognize anew the gap between the responses they had submitted and the enacted provisions.

The law had already been enacted.

Being before enforcement did not mean it could easily be stopped.

Changing the law itself would in principle require legislative amendment. However, there was still room for consideration regarding concrete operational standards. They could organize the problems, demand explanations from the administration, and seek amendment if necessary. The lawyer explained that it was necessary to clearly distinguish matters finalized under law, interpretive issues, and parts that could change through future operation. That was an important point for the three. Merely reacting emotionally would change nothing. What was the problem? Which rights were restricted, and on what basis?

And was that restriction truly necessary?

First, those things needed to be made clear.

◇

By the time the report ended, the atmosphere in the reception room had changed completely.

The fact that the three had been laughing at first felt like a distant past. The client closed the thick report and asked the lawyer for one more task. He wanted the explanation organized so that hunters who were not legal experts could understand it.

"Understood. How many people are you thinking of?"

"For now, ten."

The lawyer's brow moved slightly.

"...Ten?"

"Yeah. Eventually it might become eighteen."

Hearing that number, the lawyer lost his words again.

There were eighteen S-rank hunters in Japan. In other words, that meant all of them.

"...That is, well..."

"Sensei, it's showing on your face."

The three laughed. The lawyer had no choice but to smile wryly this time as well.

But he had no hesitation in accepting the request. He would create materials distinguishing matters finalized under law, interpretive issues, and parts that could change through future operation, and promised to continue advising as necessary. What they were seeking was not special treatment. Those who took on danger should receive compensation for it. If work is requested, conditions should be presented and payment made. If obligations are imposed, the basis should be explained.

And they should not demand as a matter of course the results someone risked their life to achieve.

It was only that.

After leaving the law office, the three exchanged brief words while waiting for the elevator.

"...Should we talk to the rest of them too?"

"Yeah. This isn't just our problem."

"First, ten people."

The doors opened.

The three got in side by side.

Each of them held a copy of the report.

Its contents were about to be seen by even more hunters.