chapter04 · 123-sidestory21
Side Story Act.21: Whose Organization Is It?
JHA Tokyo Headquarters.
Several weeks had passed since the report that all eighteen domestic S-rank hunters had gathered in Nagoya. There was no information that they had begun organized protest activities. There was no report that they had refused cooperation with the JHA. The eighteen continued their work in their respective activity regions as before. However, within a portion of Tokyo headquarters, vigilance toward their movements continued.
At a time when enforcement of the Magami Law was approaching, all domestic S-ranks had begun communicating without going through the JHA. That was a change that could not be ignored when considering future system operation.
Though the executives from former hunter backgrounds held a different view. Rather than treating the Nagoya meeting itself as a problem, why had the eighteen felt the need to gather?
Shouldn't they think about the reason? They argued so.
However, before a concrete response was decided, a new matter was brought to Tokyo headquarters.
The sender was the WHA.
The content was a formal request for negotiations regarding Rokko Mountain Dungeon.
◇
Rokko Mountain Dungeon.
The place where Magami Koichiro stepped in at seventeen and returned after achieving complete conquest eight years later. Currently, the dungeon was in a state different from normal clearing targets.
Entry by anyone other than the complete conqueror was restricted, and clearing activities by ordinary hunters were not being conducted. And from the examples of other completely conquered dungeons, the possibility of a Resource Vault existing had also been pointed out.
The dungeon itself could become a base for continuous resource supply. For the state, its value was extremely large. However, there was a problem. The authority related to the management of the Resource Vault was not something granted by the JHA. It was an authority given directly by the dungeon to the complete conqueror. And the person holding that authority, Magami Koichiro, had already left the JHA and transferred to the WHA. The current request had come from that WHA. To consider a policy for the negotiations, an executive meeting was held at Tokyo headquarters.
◇
The upper management of JHA Tokyo headquarters was composed of people with roughly three backgrounds.
About one-quarter amakudari appointments. About half career-track officials from administrative organs.
And about one-quarter retired former hunters. Administrative-side personnel accounted for three-quarters of the total. Therefore, the organization's operating policies inevitably centered on the administrative side's thinking. Regarding the current Rokko Mountain negotiations as well, that was initially the case.
The public nature of the Resource Vault.
The impact on national resource supply.
The management responsibility of the dungeon.
Based on those, it was necessary to secure a certain degree of administrative involvement.
When a career-track executive explained, several of the amakudari executives nodded.
"Regarding the complete conqueror's authority as well, some kind of institutional framework will be necessary."
"There is also a possibility that similar cases will occur in the future. We should organize this response as a precedent."
The discussion proceeded in the direction of how far administrative management authority could be secured.
It was then.
"...May I say something?"
Director Sakakibara Soichiro, who came from a former hunter background, spoke.
Until then, he had barely spoken.
"From earlier, the talk has continued about management and restrictions, but I want to confirm one thing."
Sakakibara looked around the conference room.
"The administrator authority granted to a complete conqueror—who granted it?"
"It is an authority obtained through complete conquest of a dungeon, but—"
"It was not granted by the JHA, correct?"
"...Yes."
"Nor was it granted by the state."
"That is correct."
Sakakibara nodded slowly.
"Then why are we proceeding with the discussion on the premise of restricting that authority?"
A slight silence arose in the conference room. A career-track executive answered.
"As a state, we have a responsibility to secure the stable supply of important resources. For that purpose, a certain degree of institutional management is necessary."
"I understand that resources are important."
Sakakibara responded in a calm voice.
"But just because resources are important does not mean we are allowed to freely restrict rights that others risked their lives to obtain."
"This is not about freely restricting. It is about adjustment with the public interest."
"If it's adjustment, then we should negotiate."
Sakakibara answered immediately.
"If necessary, we should present appropriate compensation. Why are we thinking of methods to restrict from the start?"
The atmosphere in the conference room began to change little by little.
◇
"...Just because a right exists does not mean its exercise is recognized without limit."
Another career-track executive spoke. As a principle of the legal system, that itself was not wrong. Sakakibara did not deny that point either.
"That is correct."
Sakakibara nodded.
"Then what specifically needs to be restricted?"
"That would be based on the stability of resource supply, security needs, and so on..."
"What danger exists, and why is that restriction necessary? Are there no other methods? Have you examined that far?"
The response cut off.
"Just because it is important to the state is not enough of a reason."
Sakakibara closed the documents in his hand.
"Also, there is something you all seem to have forgotten."
Saying that, he turned his eyes to the large monitor in the conference room.
"...Have you confirmed the combat records of Sakaihigashi Dungeon?"
Many of those present nodded. The footage from when Magami Koichiro completely conquered the country's second dungeon. Its content had been shared at Tokyo headquarters as well.
"Then let us watch it once more."
When Sakakibara operated his terminal, footage was projected on the large monitor.
Sakaihigashi Dungeon. The battle between Magami Koichiro and the powerful non-biological entity that existed in the dungeon's deepest part. On screen, offense and defense surpassing common sense unfolded.
Speed at which ordinary hunters could not even react. Destruction that engulfed the surroundings.
A battle where a single blow could obliterate an ordinary human without a trace. There was something there that the numbers in the reports could not convey. The expressions of the former hunter group watching the footage were stern. They had actually dived into dungeons during their active days. They had fought non-biological entities and seen comrades wounded. They knew the fear that they themselves might die. That was precisely why they understood the abnormality of the footage. And also, that even if they stood on this battlefield, they would be able to do nothing.
Eventually the footage stopped.
"...This is the battle at Sakaihigashi."
Sakakibara pointed at the screen.
"During our active days, was there anyone who could fight an opponent like this?"
No one answered.
"And Rokko Mountain."
Sakakibara continued.
"The dungeon Magami Koichiro spent eight years completely conquering. In its deepest part, there was an existence called the wicked goddess."
The conference room's gazes gathered.
"It is said to be a monster even more powerful than the opponent he fought at Sakaihigashi."
Silence fell. Regarding the battle that unfolded in the deepest part of Rokko Mountain, no complete record exists. What happened there, what kind of battle Magami Koichiro went through to win. No one in this room knew all of it. Sakakibara slowly looked around the conference room.
"We do not even know what happened in the deepest part of Rokko Mountain."
He paused once.
"Even so, there is one certain thing."
"...What is that?"
"Not a single one of us fought for eight years in that man's place."
No one said anything back.
"That man risked his life and achieved complete conquest. As a result, the dungeon granted him rights."
Sakakibara's voice lowered.
"And we, who came later, would restrict them because they are important to the state?"
Then he asked.
"By what right, exactly?"
◇
For a while, the conference room was completely silent.
However, the career-track executives also had administrative responsibility. Respecting Magami Koichiro's rights and considering national resource policy did not necessarily contradict each other.
That was precisely why they believed institutional adjustment was necessary.
"...I understand what you are saying."
One of the career-track officials chose his words carefully.
"However, we cannot abandon our responsibility as a state."
"Who said to abandon it?"
Sakakibara asked back.
"I am saying negotiate. Treat the other party as a rights holder."
"But if the negotiations fail..."
"Review the conditions and renegotiate."
"And if agreement still cannot be reached?"
"Then it means agreement could not be reached."
Sakakibara answered simply.
"If the other party has no right to refuse, that is not called negotiation."
In a corner of the conference room, an amakudari executive furrowed his brow.
Should a matter important to the state be left solely to an individual's will? Such a view was a natural reaction for someone involved in administration. However, Sakakibara did not stop there.
"In the first place, what do we exist for?"
No one answered immediately.
"The JHA is an organization for supporting hunters' activities and managing dungeons, correct?"
"Of course."
"Then who is it that dives into dungeons, fights non-biological entities, and brings back materials?"
"...Hunters."
"Indeed."
Sakakibara nodded quietly.
"Hunters risk their lives to fight and bring back materials. Those materials are traded and distributed through society. We do the work of supporting those activities."
Then he looked around the conference room.
"To put it bluntly, we are in a position of receiving the scraps of the rewards hunters earn by risking their lives."
Several executives frowned in displeasure. They probably felt resistance to having their responsibility as an administrative organ expressed in such terms.
Sakakibara was aware of that too.
"Of course, I am not saying the JHA's work is unnecessary."
Sakakibara continued.
"Safety measures, transaction infrastructure, hunter support—all are necessary. Administrative expertise is also indispensable."
There, he paused once.
"But you see, that is work that exists precisely because hunters risk their lives to fight."
Anger mixed into Sakakibara's voice once more.
"When did it become the reverse?"
The atmosphere in the conference room tensed.
"When did we become the side that grants rights to hunters?"
A career-track executive argued back.
"However, the JHA has supervisory authority based on law."
"I know there is supervisory authority."
Sakakibara fixed his gaze on the other.
"But does that mean we can make what hunters risked their lives to obtain into our property?"
"...That is not what I mean."
"Then we should think from that premise from the start."
Sakakibara closed the documents.
"Magami Koichiro spent eight years completely conquering Rokko Mountain. And now we would restrict the rights he obtained as a result, for the state's convenience."
Then he continued slowly.
"What were we doing while that man was fighting?"
There was no reply.
"At the very least, we did not fight in his place. We could not even go to help him."
Sakakibara turned his gaze to the frozen footage.
"To a person who risked his life to fight, we come later and say, 'We will decide your share'?"
No one could answer immediately.
◇
A heavy silence continued in the conference room.
Eventually, one of the amakudari executives spoke.
"...It seems we may have gotten the order a little wrong."
Sakakibara shook his head.
"Not a little."
There was no longer even anger in his voice.
"It is fundamentally different in our way of thinking."
Sakakibara looked around at everyone in the conference room.
"We do not exist to stand above hunters."
And he continued quietly.
"We exist so that hunters can fight."
That was, for the executives from former hunter backgrounds, an utterly obvious recognition.
However, in the upper management of the JHA, which had continued to expand as an administrative organization, that recognition had been gradually fading before anyone noticed.
Managing hunters.
Supervising activities.
Granting qualifications and revoking them.
Maintaining systems.
In the course of repeating those operations, a sense had arisen that the JHA existed above the hunters. Of course, not all administrative-side executives thought that way.
There were also those seriously considering the systems necessary to support the field. However, in the current Rokko Mountain negotiations, that difference in thinking had clearly surfaced.
The former hunter group was only one-quarter of the upper management. The power map within the organization would not change from this one meeting. Even so, no one could present a clear rebuttal to their argument. On what basis would they restrict the rights a complete conqueror risked his life to obtain? No one had a sufficient answer prepared for that question.
◇
At the end of the meeting, the agenda finally returned to its original purpose.
The negotiations regarding Rokko Mountain Dungeon requested by the WHA.
First, formally confirm the content. What the other side is seeking and what conditions they are presenting. On that basis, organize what the JHA can respond to.
At the very least, the policy premised on restricting the complete conqueror's authority was deemed to require reconsideration. That did not mean the former hunter group's opinion was fully adopted. The administrative side still had concerns regarding resource supply and security.
The discussion regarding future system design was also not finished.
However, one thing had changed. Before the question of what the JHA could manage, the question of whose rights they were dealing with was now placed first.
After the meeting ended, Sakakibara and the other executives from former hunter backgrounds stood from their seats.
Their expressions did not show triumph.
Rather, the color of fatigue was strong.
They had not wanted to defeat their colleagues in the same organization.
They had simply wanted them not to forget what must not be forgotten.
What those who dive into dungeons are risking in battle.
And that the organization called the JHA exists to support those activities.
◇
At the same time, in various regions of the country, the eighteen S-rank hunters were living their respective daily lives.
Those diving into dungeons.
Those selling materials.
Those responding to requests from regional branches and heading to subjugate non-biological entities.
They did not know about the discussion held at Tokyo headquarters.
They also did not know that Sakakibara and the other executives from former hunter backgrounds had raised their voices to protect hunters' rights in a place they did not know about.
However, what the eighteen discussed in Nagoya and what the former hunter group argued at Tokyo headquarters had something in common.
Taking on danger by one's own will. Having what was obtained by risking one's life treated fairly.
And that providing necessary cooperation and having obligations unilaterally imposed are different.
Their positions, experiences, and ways of thinking differed. Even so, the line that those who had lived in dungeons tried to protect was surprisingly similar.
The negotiations over Rokko Mountain had only just begun.
What impact its conclusion would have on the future hunter system, no one knew. However, in the conference room of JHA Tokyo headquarters, one question was thrust forward that day.
Whose organization is the JHA?
There had arisen a need to reconsider that answer once more.