chapter04 · 145-sidestory29

Side Story Act.29: The Wedge

After finishing the reading of the materials, the eighteen exchanged opinions for a while.

Regarding this round of negotiations, the first thing they confirmed was the fact that the four months of negotiations had by no means been meaningless. Facility management, security systems, consistency with domestic law, division of responsibility in the event of an accident. From the public materials, it could be read that the practical officials of both the Japanese government and the WHA had repeatedly coordinated toward the resolution of concrete problems.

Just because the negotiations ended in failure did not mean the efforts up to that point should be denied.

On this point, there was no disagreement among the eighteen.

On the other hand, regarding the discussions on resource designation, a clear problem existed. The fact that the Japanese government wished for oil designation was itself an understandable judgment. Considering domestic energy supply and economic benefits, there was sufficient reason to seek oil. However, wishing for something and having its realization guaranteed were different. The authority for resource designation belonged to the complete conqueror, Magami Koichiro. The WHA had no designation authority and could not guarantee his intentions. That fact had been repeatedly explained from the early stages of the negotiations. Nevertheless, the guarantee of oil designation was made a condition for final agreement, and that policy was maintained.

Within the scope of the materials the eighteen could confirm, it was clear that this condition was the main cause of the failure of the negotiations.

However, regarding who within the government decided the final policy and through what process, there remained non-disclosed portions. Therefore, they agreed that attributing responsibility to a specific individual or department should be avoided. Their purpose was not to seek out and condemn the people in charge. It was to organize the confirmable facts and evaluate the results from the standpoint of active hunters.

◇

The discussion eventually shifted to the authority of the complete conqueror and the recognition of his achievement.

The eighteen were all S-rank hunters positioned at the highest level within the country. They were people who had dived into dungeons for many years, fought dangerous monsters, and accumulated experience sometimes while losing comrades. However, none among them had achieved complete conquest.

Regarding the authority granted only to complete conquerors, they had institutional knowledge, but they did not possess the experience of having accomplished that feat themselves.

That was precisely why they did not speak lightly of its difficulty.

The deeper one goes into a dungeon, the more danger increases, and responding to unknown environments and monsters requires judgment and experience beyond simple combat ability. And no matter how excellent a hunter one might be, survival was not guaranteed. Magami Koichiro spent eight years completely conquering Rokko Mountain Dungeon. The meaning of that fact was not limited to the authority to use a Resource Vault. What the eighteen questioned through the negotiation materials this time was the point of how much the achievement and intentions of the complete conqueror himself—who made its use possible—had been respected, while the economic value and national necessity of the Resource Vault were discussed in detail.

Of course, based on negotiation records alone, they could not assert that all government officials lacked respect for the complete conqueror.

However, at least from the confirmable course of the discussions, it was difficult to evaluate that the stance of respecting the authority belonging to the person himself had been sufficiently reflected in the final negotiation conditions. It should not be denied that the state seeks cooperation from a complete conqueror. The benefits brought by a Resource Vault could extend to society as a whole, and there was rationality in the government examining its utilization.

But since the complete conqueror's authority was recognized under the system, his own intentions must be respected regarding its exercise. Seeking cooperation and treating cooperation as a matter of course were different. This distinction was one of the problems that had not been sufficiently organized in this round of negotiations, the eighteen thought.

◇

Next, what was examined was their own position.

The eighteen were active hunters operating within Japan. They understood that society expected a certain role from them regarding responses to dungeon disasters and ensuring the lives and safety of the people. Regarding their willingness to cooperate to the extent possible in the event of a national crisis, all shared that intention. However, that cooperation did not mean unconditional obedience.

Hunters are not the property of the state; they are individuals each with their own rights and intentions.

If participation in dangerous missions is sought, the purpose and danger of the mission, where responsibility lies, compensation, and the conditions under which refusal is permitted must be clear. A distinction must also be made between matters that create legal obligations and cooperation requests based on the individual's consent.

These problems were not limited to complete conquerors.

The problem that arose this time over Magami Koichiro's authority could occur for other hunters in the future. At that time, if the mechanisms to protect individual rights were not sufficiently in place, similar conflicts could repeat. The eighteen evaluated that the WHA had consistently respected the complete conqueror's authority in these negotiations. At the same time, they thought that the JHA, which handles registration and qualification management of domestic hunters, also needed to clarify its rights protection policy and procedures. That was not a denial of the JHA's activities to date. While maintaining its role of cooperative relationship with the government and ensuring domestic safety, how to protect the rights of individual hunters.

It was necessary to clarify the organization's stance and establish a system that would continue even if the man in charge changed.

◇

As a result of the discussion, the eighteen agreed on a policy of publishing a joint statement.

However, careful examination was repeated regarding its content. It was not a document aimed at criticizing the government, nor a document unconditionally supporting the WHA's position. Based on confirmable materials, they would organize the history of the negotiations and distinguish points that could be evaluated from points where problems remained.

On that basis, they would clarify their position as active S-rank hunters.

The draft was revised many times. Expressions were organized so that matters confirmable as facts and the eighteen's own evaluations and requests would not be confused. Regarding non-disclosed information, speculation was avoided, and regarding where responsibility lay, assertions were refrained from.

It was also explicitly stated that the document did not speak for Magami Koichiro himself.

They had not been requested by Magami, nor had they been approached by the WHA. They were simply publishing the results of their own investigation and examination.

Evening.

The final draft was distributed to all eighteen. Each confirmed the wording, and final opinions were exchanged regarding expression and content. And all agreed. That night, the joint statement by the eighteen active domestic S-rank hunters was published.

◇

Joint Statement by the Eighteen Active Domestic S-Rank Hunters

Regarding the Indefinite Suspension of the Rokko Mountain Dungeon Resource Vault Operation Negotiations

I. Recognition Regarding the Course of the Negotiations

As a result of confirming public materials and obtainable negotiation records, we have confirmed that during the four months of negotiations, practical coordination was proceeding regarding facility management, security, division of legal responsibility, and other matters. We evaluate that the practical officials of both the Japanese government and the WHA continuously worked toward the establishment of an agreement. On the other hand, regarding resource designation, despite repeated explanations that no designation authority existed other than with the complete conqueror, a guarantee of oil designation was made a condition for final agreement. Based on confirmable materials, we judge that this condition was the main cause of the failure of the negotiations.

Furthermore, since non-disclosed portions exist in the final decision-making process within the government, we do not assert responsibility regarding specific individuals or departments.

II. Cooperation with the State and Our Position

We, as active S-rank hunters operating within Japan, have the intention to continue cooperating to the extent possible regarding responses to dungeon disasters, ensuring the lives and safety of the people, and other activities contributing to the public interest. We also fully recognize the importance of the role hunters can play in national crises. However, that cooperation does not mean unconditionally abandoning the rights and intentions of individual hunters.

The necessity of the state and the rights of the individual must both be respected, and when seeking cooperation, the purpose, scope, responsibility, compensation, and the individual's intentions must be appropriately considered.

Furthermore, we believe that matters creating legal obligations and cooperation requests based on the individual's consent must be clearly distinguished.

III. Respect for the Complete Conqueror and Respect for Authority

Complete conquest is a feat accompanied by extremely high danger and difficulty.

None among us eighteen has achieved complete conquest. However, precisely because we have experienced the dangers of dungeons as active hunters, we understand that this feat is not easily accomplished. In these negotiations, while the economic value and national necessity of the Resource Vault were repeatedly discussed, we cannot help but harbor strong doubts as to whether sufficient respect was shown for the intentions of the complete conqueror himself—who made its use possible—and for his achievement.

We do not assert the presence or absence of recognition or respect on the part of individual parties involved based solely on negotiation records. However, it is difficult to evaluate that the stance of respecting the complete conqueror's intentions was sufficiently reflected in the final negotiation conditions.

The authority obtained by a complete conqueror belongs to that person.

We do not deny that the state seeks cooperation. However, seeking cooperation and having a third party guarantee the individual's intentions must be clearly distinguished. We evaluate the WHA's response in these negotiations, which respected the complete conqueror's intentions and consistently protected his authority.

IV. Regarding the Protection of Domestic Hunters' Rights

The problem this time is not limited to a single complete conqueror.

The possibility of conflict between cooperation requests from the state and the rights of individual hunters may arise in the future.

We request that the JHA clarify institutionally its response policy when cooperation requests from the government conflict with the rights of individual hunters, matters requiring the individual's consent, procedures for filing objections, and mechanisms for rights protection. These protections must not depend on the judgment or goodwill of a specific man in charge. While recognizing the role the JHA plays in maintaining domestic safety and order, we expect the establishment of a system capable of continuously protecting the rights of individual hunters.

V. Regarding the Future

We publish this statement not for the purpose of supporting or condemning any specific political force. Nor do we speak as representatives of Magami Koichiro-shi.

This statement expresses our position as active hunters, based on our own experience and confirmable materials.

In order to build a relationship of mutual trust and cooperation between the state and hunters, we hope that the circumstances that led to the failure of these negotiations will be appropriately verified and reflected in future system operation.

End of statement.

Jointly signed by the eighteen active domestic S-rank hunters.