chapter04 · 156-sidestory33

Side Story Act.33: The Call for Reform

The next morning.

In the conference room of the Prime Minister's Official Residence, the relevant cabinet ministers had been gathered since early morning.

The Chief Cabinet Secretary, the Minister of Non-Biological Countermeasures, the Finance Minister, the Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry, and the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare.

Behind them were the administrative vice-ministers and other senior officials from each ministry. The agenda concerned the joint emergency meeting between the government and the JHA held the previous day. The joint statement by the eighteen active S-rank hunters in Japan. And the gap between the field and the administration that the former hunter directors had appealed about at the meeting.

The Prime Minister quietly closed the report on the desk.

"...I have received the report on yesterday's meeting."

No one spoke.

"I hear that a former hunter director removed his prosthetic hand during the meeting."

"...Yes."

The Minister of Non-Biological Countermeasures answered.

"I heard that not only his left hand but one eye was also prosthetic."

"That is correct."

The Prime Minister was silent for a while.

"That person had given up on conveying the voices of the field."

He looked down at the documents.

"And eighteen active S-rank hunters issued a joint statement asking for respect for their rights."

The Prime Minister raised his face.

"...Since when did we become a position that makes hunters obey, rather than a position that protects them?"

A heavy silence fell.

"Of course, I am not saying that administrative management is unnecessary. Dungeon safety management, material distribution, response to national crises. All are necessary work."

The Prime Minister continued.

"But having the authority to manage and being able to use that authority however one likes are completely different things."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary nodded quietly.

"It seems necessary to conduct a comprehensive review of the Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures' system operation."

"Yes. But that alone is not enough."

The Prime Minister looked around at the attendees.

"This time, we will review hunter administration as a whole."

◇

"First, the Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures."

At the Prime Minister's words, the minister in charge straightened his posture.

"Cooperation requests to hunters, qualification suspension, activity restrictions, compensation, appeals. Please investigate not only the current laws and regulations but also how they have actually been operated."

"Understood."

"In particular, to what extent has the individual's consent been respected? Was cooperation effectively forced by indicating administrative disadvantages? Please confirm those points with priority."

The minister's expression tightened.

"...You mean the actual state of operation."

"Naturally. Even if the rules are fine, if the way they are used is problematic, it is meaningless."

The Prime Minister picked up another document.

"And regarding the Rokko Mountain Dungeon Resource Vault operation negotiations, we will also investigate the process by which the negotiation conditions were decided."

The atmosphere in the room changed.

"The WHA does not have the authority to designate the resources produced in the Resource Vault. That should have been understood from the early stages of the negotiations."

"...Yes."

"Nevertheless, you continued to demand a guarantee of oil designation as a mandatory condition. Who decided that condition, and who instructed that it be maintained? Please clarify the circumstances."

The Prime Minister paused.

"I will not allow responsibility to be pushed solely onto the person in charge of the negotiations in the field."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary nodded.

"We will confirm, including the political side involved in the decision-making."

"Please do."

The Prime Minister continued quietly.

"Trying to secure necessary resources is not wrong in itself."

Then he strengthened his voice slightly.

"But just because something is necessary does not mean you can make the other party exercise authority they do not possess."

◇

"Next, the Ministry of Finance."

The Finance Minister raised his face.

"Yes."

"Please thoroughly investigate the tax system related to hunters and the execution status of related budgets."

"...Both the tax system and the budget?"

"Yes."

The Prime Minister nodded.

"How much tax has the state collected from the rewards hunters earn and from the profits of selling materials? Meanwhile, how much budget has been allocated to their safety, compensation for injuries, medical treatment, social reintegration, and post-retirement livelihood support?"

A senior Finance Ministry official spoke.

"Regarding taxation, it is being conducted appropriately in accordance with current laws—"

"Appropriate taxation and the overall system being appropriate are not the same thing."

The Prime Minister quietly cut him off.

"I am not questioning taxation itself."

He turned a page.

"Expensive equipment, consumables, medical expenses, costs to continue activities. Are these being handled appropriately under the tax system?"

The Finance Minister listened silently.

"And if the Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures or the JHA had submitted budget requests necessary for hunter protection, please also investigate how those were assessed."

"You mean go back through past budget assessments."

"Yes."

The Prime Minister looked at the Finance Minister.

"I do not intend to assume that the Ministry of Finance was only thinking about collecting taxes."

There, he paused once.

"But I would like you to submit materials sufficient to explain that this was not the case."

The Finance Minister nodded slowly.

"...Understood. We will verify from both the tax system and budget perspectives."

"Please do."

The Prime Minister looked down at a section of the report.

"At yesterday's meeting, one director apparently said this: 'I lost my left hand and one eye, but I was able to return alive.'"

No one interjected.

"What kind of support was that person able to receive when injured? What was he unable to receive? I still do not know."

The Prime Minister slowly raised his face.

"I cannot say that the state has done enough while remaining ignorant."

The Finance Minister bowed deeply.

◇

"I will also ask for cooperation from the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry and the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare."

At the Prime Minister's words, the two ministers straightened their postures.

"I would like the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry to organize the distribution system for dungeon-derived materials, support for the equipment industry, and the relationship between resource policy and hunters' rights."

"Understood."

"Even if a material is necessary for the state, hunters who have legitimately obtained it have rights. You must not obscure those rights on the grounds of necessity."

The Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry nodded.

"We will consider mechanisms for paying fair compensation, such as priority purchasing and long-term contracts."

"Please do."

Next, the Prime Minister turned his gaze to the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare.

"I would like the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare to confirm treatment for the injured, support for those with disabilities, return to work, and compensation for bereaved families."

"Yes."

"There may be cases where hunters cannot be sufficiently protected by the same systems as ordinary workers. But that does not mean they should be left in the gaps between systems."

"We will verify, including connections with related systems."

"Yes."

The Prime Minister gazed at the eighteen's joint statement on the desk.

"What they are seeking is not privilege."

And he continued quietly.

"It is that society bears a commensurate responsibility for a job that risks one's life."

◇

"...And then, regarding the JHA."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary distributed new documents.

"The current board has twenty members. Five from former hunter backgrounds, ten from administrative career backgrounds, and five amakudari from ministries and agencies."

The Prime Minister gazed at those numbers.

"One reason the voices of the field became harder to reach must lie in this composition."

"However, simply changing the board composition may not solve the problem."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary answered.

"That is correct."

The Prime Minister nodded.

"That is precisely why we will change both the composition and the system."

The reform proposal distributed included a new board composition.

Former hunter directors: eight.

Career directors: ten.

Ministry-origin directors: two.

Total: twenty.

"So you will increase former hunters and reduce the amakudari slots."

"Yes. However, we do not intend to exclude ministry-origin directors."

The Prime Minister indicated a document listing the names of four ministries.

Ministry of Finance.

Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures.

Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry.

Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare.

"We will consider a system in which these four ministries send two members on a rotating basis."

"Two at all times."

"Yes."

The Prime Minister continued.

"We will not require these two to hold hunter qualifications."

The Finance Minister raised his face slightly.

"...Qualifications are not required?"

"Yes. Because the role we seek is different."

The Prime Minister answered clearly.

"Matters of the field will be handled by former hunter directors and career directors with practical experience."

Then he looked at the four ministers in turn.

"I would like the two ministry-origin members to play the role of reflecting the systems and budgets the JHA needs in the administration."

"...I see."

"Simply explaining the circumstances of the ministries to the JHA is not enough."

The Prime Minister's voice grew slightly stern.

"Make the ministries understand what the JHA needs. Coordinate for that purpose. If necessary, request improvements from one's own ministry."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary wrote in the documents.

"So the position is not a liaison with ministries but a director responsible for policy coordination."

"Yes. And the results of that coordination will be subject to mandatory reporting to the board."

The Prime Minister added quietly.

"If it is a post that ends with 'they said it would be difficult,' there is no need to prepare two seats."

◇

"...The problem is the ten career-track members."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary said.

The Prime Minister nodded.

"Yes. This needs to be changed even more significantly."

The Minister of Non-Biological Countermeasures checked the documents.

"This is the proposal to add hunter qualifications and field activity experience as requirements for management promotions."

"That is correct."

A slight stir spread through the conference room.

"But wouldn't that force administrative officials into dangerous activities?"

A senior administrative official asked.

"We will not force them."

The Prime Minister answered immediately.

"Whether to become a hunter is for the individual to decide."

"...Then?"

"However, for senior management positions that manage hunters and make judgments concerning their activities and rights, we will require actual field experience."

The Prime Minister indicated the documents with his finger.

"Simply obtaining a qualification is not enough. We will add to the promotion requirements that the person has actually operated in dungeons and experienced field judgments and dangers."

"What about officials who do not become hunters?"

"They can continue working as administrative officials. Opportunities to demonstrate their expertise will of course remain."

The Prime Minister paused slightly.

"But they cannot assume a position supervising the field without knowing it."

No one answered.

"There is freedom not to become a hunter. That choice must be respected."

The Prime Minister continued.

"However, there is no need to unconditionally grant the qualifications to stand on the managing side."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary spoke.

"The criteria for field experience will need to be carefully designed. Simply demanding a number of subjugations could encourage reckless activity."

"That is correct."

The Prime Minister nodded.

"There is no need to evaluate only combat roles. Please appropriately evaluate actual field experience, including support roles and survey activities."

And he continued.

"Creating a system where people lose their lives for training would be putting the cart before the horse."

The Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare nodded quietly.

"Compensation for accidents during activities must also be considered together with the system design."

"Please do."

The Prime Minister looked around the conference room.

"We need personnel with administrative capability. I do not think an organization can be run on field experience alone."

There, he paused once.

"That is precisely why we will cultivate people who possess both."

◇

When the explanation of the reform proposal ended, the Chief Cabinet Secretary confirmed.

"Regarding the JHA board composition, changes will be made after formal discussion and necessary procedures."

"Yes. Please do not make it a reform where the government unilaterally decides personnel."

The Prime Minister nodded.

"The JHA itself needs to think about what should be changed and decide."

"We will also hear opinions from former hunter directors."

"That alone is not enough."

The Prime Minister lowered his eyes to the eighteen's joint statement.

"Please also listen to the opinions of active hunters. Not just S-ranks, but people in various positions."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary nodded.

"Understood."

"However, do not make it a meeting for the sake of creating a record of having listened to opinions."

The Prime Minister said clearly.

"How were the opinions received handled? If they could not be adopted, what was the reason? Please create a mechanism that can explain that far."

Then his expression softened slightly.

"At yesterday's meeting, one director apparently said this."

The Prime Minister read a passage from the report.

"'I came here intending to protect, but I became good at lining up reasons why I couldn't.'"

Silence fell over the conference room.

"...I want the JHA going forward to be an organization that thinks about how it can protect, rather than searching for reasons why it cannot."

◇

The meeting continued after that. The scope of the reform was wide.

Some matters required legal amendments, while others could be handled by changes to ministerial ordinances or internal regulations.

Some required budget reallocation. Others required new system design.

And some could be improved simply by changing past operational practices. To organize these, it was decided to establish a cross-ministerial verification system led by the Prime Minister's Office.

The Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures: a comprehensive review of authority and operation.

The Ministry of Finance: verification of tax systems and budget assessments.

The Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry: institutional organization of material distribution and related industries.

The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare: verification of protection for the injured and bereaved, and support for social reintegration.

And the JHA: reform discussions on board composition and personnel systems.

Each ministry and agency was to first submit current systems and past operational records.

Based on that, they would compile reform proposals separating matters to be prioritized for change and matters requiring legal amendments.

"...This will be a considerable amount of work."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary gazed at the stack of documents.

"I suppose so."

The Prime Minister answered quietly.

"But it is necessary work."

Then he looked at the clock.

"Time may be taken. Do not omit necessary discussion."

The attendees nodded.

"However—"

The Prime Minister looked around at everyone once more.

"I will not permit taking time before starting."

◇

After the meeting ended, the Chief Cabinet Secretary remained alone with the Prime Minister.

"...Prime Minister."

"What is it?"

"This reform will likely invite considerable opposition."

"I suppose so."

The Prime Minister admitted it readily.

"Changing the JHA board composition. Changing the promotion requirements for career officials. Investigating past budget assessments by the Ministry of Finance. None of these will be easily accepted by those involved."

"I am aware."

"Even so, can you proceed?"

The Prime Minister thought for a moment.

"...At yesterday's meeting, there was a director who removed his prosthetic hand."

"Yes."

"I heard that he did not reattach it until the end."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary nodded silently.

"I was not there."

The Prime Minister turned his gaze outside the window.

"But reading the report, I thought."

"...What did you think?"

"Have we not demanded too much of those who work risking their lives?"

The Prime Minister slowly turned around.

"Cooperate with us. Bring back resources. Stand up in national crises."

And he continued quietly.

"Then, when those people ask something of us, how seriously has the state responded?"

The Chief Cabinet Secretary did not answer.

"The eighteen are still saying they will cooperate."

The Prime Minister gazed at the joint statement on the desk.

"We cannot keep relying on those words."

"...Yes."

"And regarding the Rokko Mountain negotiations."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary raised his face.

"For the time being, please refrain from seeking a resumption."

"Is that all right?"

"Yes."

The Prime Minister nodded.

"Even if we ask to resume negotiations solely for our own convenience, the lost trust will not return."

He lowered his voice slightly.

"First, we must change ourselves."

The Chief Cabinet Secretary bowed deeply.

"Understood."

◇

That day, instructions regarding the reform were transmitted to each ministry and agency.

At the Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures, records of past administrative dispositions and cooperation requests began to be collected.

At the Ministry of Finance, an investigation was ordered into hunter-related tax systems and budget assessment materials, including past years. At the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry and the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare as well, verification by the relevant departments began.

And at JHA headquarters.

Sakakibara Soichiro also received notice regarding the reform discussions from the Prime Minister's Office.

Review of board composition. Change in the role of ministry-origin directors. A management promotion system premised on hunter qualifications and field activity experience for career officials. After reading the documents to the end, Sakakibara let out a quiet breath.

"...So it has really started moving."

But this did not mean the reform was decided.

The JHA board has twenty directors. Each has their own position, their own thoughts, and things they seek to protect. To formally adopt the reform proposal, discussion and decision by the board were necessary. Sakakibara gazed at the eighteen's joint statement placed on the desk.

And he remembered the figure of the director who had removed his prosthetic hand at the previous day's meeting.

"...This time, for sure."

He muttered quietly. Those who know the field raise their voices to protect the field.

Those who know the administration turn those voices into systems. And those with connections to ministries act to realize the necessary policies and budgets. The shape of the organization they should aim for was beginning to become visible.

But whether it could be realized depended on the board from now on.

Sakakibara opened the agenda draft for the next board meeting. There, a new item had been added.

"Regarding JHA Organizational Reform and Review of Board Composition"

Sakakibara gazed at those words for a while. Eventually, he nodded quietly.

"...Well then, the real work starts here."

◇

The joint statement by the eighteen active S-rank hunters in Japan.

That statement was a renewed questioning of hunter rights directed at the government and the JHA.

The eighteen had not demanded reform of the administrative structure. They had not specified the board composition. They had simply asked for respect for their intentions and rights, and for the state to fulfill a commensurate responsibility for a job that risks lives. But that obvious demand forcibly brought to the surface the distortions in the systems that had been accumulated over the years.

The government began to move toward reform. The JHA was also about to step into discussions to change its own nature. Of course, an organization does not change with a single order.

Long-standing practices, authority, and personnel systems would not be easily changed.

Even so, the reason they had to change had already been shown.

A single prosthetic hand placed on the desk in that conference room.

And eighteen signatures.

This time, the questions they thrust forward had to be answered with systems and action.

Japan's hunter administration had finally taken its first step toward reform.