chapter04 · 117-sidestory19
Side Story Act.19: The Pride of Eighteen
A certain conference facility in Nagoya.
In one of its rooms, eighteen S-rank hunters operating within Japan had gathered.
Seven from Tokyo, three from Kansai, two from Tohoku, one from Hokkaido, two from Chugoku, one from Shikoku, and two from Kyushu. All of the S-rank hunters operating in Japan.
Some interacted regularly; others only knew names and faces. Among them were quite a few combinations meeting for the first time.
Their activity regions and clearing policies differed.
Some led parties, while others dove into dungeons alone. Some actively cooperated with the JHA, while others kept their involvement to the bare minimum.
They were not comrades belonging to the same organization. Each was a hunter who had operated based on their own judgment. That all eighteen of them were gathered in one place was, in itself, an extraordinary event.
In one corner of the conference room, several legal experts had set up seats. Centered on the lawyer who had first been consulted by the three from Tokyo, they specialized in different fields: administrative law, property rights, contractual relationships, and so on. Before them were piled materials organizing information on the Magami Law, the hunter qualification system, the JHA's organizational structure, and more.
When the start time arrived, one of the male hunters from Tokyo gave a brief greeting.
The purpose of this meeting was to confirm how the newly enacted Magami Law would affect their activities and to exchange opinions on how to respond going forward. It was not predetermined that they would resolve anything. Nor was there any need to follow anyone's opinion.
It was, purely and simply, a meeting that each of the eighteen had chosen to attend by their own will.
◇
The meeting began with the legal experts explaining the Magami Law.
Although the law had been enacted, it had not yet come into force. Therefore, it was necessary to consider separately the provisions currently finalized and the parts that could become problematic through future operation. The agenda included cooperation in national emergencies, normal-time activity obligations, suspension or restriction of hunter qualifications, and the handling of rare materials.
All were issues directly concerning future hunter activities.
Particular attention focused on the difference between cooperation with the state and activity obligations. None of the eighteen denied cooperation in national crises itself. For them, who had responded to emergencies such as stampedes in various regions, lending their strength when necessary was by no means a special idea. However, being asked for cooperation and being ordered to act were different. Who would certify a state of emergency? How much danger would they be required to accept? Would the individual have room to refuse? What about compensation for injury or death?
Additionally, there was the problem that concentrating the limited S-rank hunters in a specific region would reduce the defensive capacity of the regions where they normally operated. The female hunter from Hokkaido pointed out precisely that. If a stampede occurred in her home region while she was dispatched elsewhere, who would respond? Sending highly capable individuals to where they are needed—it wasn't a problem that could be solved so simply. The legal experts organized these questions into matters that could be judged under the current system and matters that needed to be clarified going forward.
Whether they prioritized cooperation with the state or individual freedom, all were cautious about imposing unlimited obligations on dangerous activities. What they sought was not only the freedom to refuse cooperation. It was a very practical demand: even when cooperating, they wanted responsibility and conditions to be made clear.
◇
Next, an explanation of the JHA's organizational structure was given.
The Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures, and the JHA which handled its practical operations. JHA headquarters, and the regional branches.
What the hunters dealt with on a daily basis was primarily the staff of the regional branches. Much of the work related to their normal activities—dungeon entry procedures, transactions of obtained items, sharing of clearing information, emergency cooperation requests—was conducted through the regional branches. However, the operational policies of the system and the decision-making of the organization as a whole were not handled by the regional branches alone.
The materials presented following that explanation drew the interest of the eighteen.
The composition of the JHA's upper management by background.
Amakudari appointments: 25 percent.
Career bureaucrats: 50 percent.
Retired former hunters: 25 percent.
In other words, three-quarters of the upper management were individuals who had no experience operating as hunters.
When those numbers were shown, a brief silence fell over the conference room.
"...Only a quarter are former hunters?"
The lawyer nodded at the question from the male hunter from Tokyo.
Administrative management and organizational operation require specialized knowledge in their respective fields. The lack of hunter experience itself could not be immediately called a problem. The eighteen understood that point. However, in an organization where the majority were people who had never experienced the field, how much were the opinions of active hunters reflected?
That was a separate issue.
"I'd be in trouble too if someone told me to do government office work."
The male hunter from Chugoku spoke while leaning back in his chair.
"But isn't the reverse the same?"
He was the man who had hesitated to participate until the end, preferring to act alone.
"Just as I don't know office work, those guys don't know our work. And yet the ones deciding how we do our work are mostly them?"
No one answered immediately.
How much say did former hunter executives actually have? To what extent were their opinions reflected in actual decision-making? Also, being a former hunter did not necessarily mean one would speak for active hunters. The composition ratio alone could not determine that much. However, the fact that three-quarters of the upper management of the organization operating the system concerning their activities were people without hunter experience was something the eighteen could not ignore.
The topic also touched on the retirement of Todo Tsuyoshi, former Osaka Branch Chief.
Information that he had retired after being summoned to Tokyo headquarters regarding Magami Koichiro's transfer to the WHA had already reached the participants. Particularly for the three from Kansai who had previously consulted Todo about legal issues, that news was concerning. Though it was impossible to assert the circumstances from outside regarding internal personnel decisions. At the meeting, the discussion settled on the need to confirm the division of authority between JHA headquarters and regional branches, and the decision-making mechanism, rather than speculating about the reason for Todo's retirement. The staff on the ground, the upper management deciding organizational policy, and the administrative organs above them.
Their respective positions and responsibilities needed to be considered separately.
◇
Next, the legal experts took up the distortions beginning to appear in the current system due to the existence of Magami Koichiro. The person who became the first in Japan to completely conquer a dungeon and has continued to accumulate clearing achievements since. Currently, he has left the JHA and operates with the WHA. His existence was bringing to the surface, one after another, problems that the hunter system had never anticipated.
The conventional system was designed around the basic activities of hunters entering dungeons, subjugating monsters, and bringing back materials. The qualification system managed by the JHA also presupposed such activities.
Dungeon entry.
Official transactions.
Use of support systems.
Suspension or restriction of qualifications constitutes a disadvantage that cannot be ignored for ordinary hunters.
However, Magami Koichiro was different.
As a complete conqueror, he possessed privileges not granted to ordinary hunters. The use of the administrator portal was one of them. And those privileges were not granted by the JHA. They were granted by the dungeon itself to the complete conqueror.
"So even if the JHA revokes his qualifications, it can't revoke Magami's privileges?"
The lawyer nodded at the male hunter from Tokyo's question.
"At the very least, there is no basis for the dungeon-side privileges being lost through qualification suspension."
It was a situation the qualification system had never anticipated.
For a person who could operate without depending on JHA qualifications, how effective could the conventional measure of qualification suspension be? That premise itself was shaking. Furthermore, the same problem existed regarding the operation of completely conquered dungeons as resource vaults. Resources obtained from dungeons hold important significance for the state and industry. However, if only the complete conqueror could operate the management functions necessary for operating a resource vault, then conventional facility management and resource management concepts could not handle it.
The state needing resources.
The state being able to operate the management functions that produce those resources.
These were completely separate issues. Even if the state claimed management authority over a dungeon, that would not enable it to use the administrator portal.
Magami Koichiro was not violating the law.
He had simply reached a realm no one had ever reached before and acquired abilities and authority the conventional system had never anticipated. Since dungeons appeared around the world, each country had been groping in the dark to build systems.
Hunter qualifications.
Dungeon management.
Dealing with monsters.
Distribution of obtained items.
They were mechanisms created to deal with unknown entities.
But with the appearance of a complete conqueror, the limits of the system that had been invisible until now were beginning to become clear. And the problem did not stop with Magami Koichiro alone.
There was a possibility that new complete conquerors would appear in the future. There might appear hunters who acquired abilities and privileges that had never been anticipated. At that time, there was no guarantee that the current system could adequately handle them. Also, a system developed to deal with a specific individual could affect the activities of other hunters.
The legal experts carefully explained that point.
"...In short, because that guy Magami pulled off something incredible, the old system's become inconvenient?"
The man from Chugoku furrowed his brow. The lawyer answered that it should be considered that the system's challenges had become manifest. Regarding the legislative purpose of the Magami Law and the scope of application of individual provisions, accurate examination was still necessary. However, it was certain that cases the conventional system could not handle had emerged.
"It's not like Magami himself did anything wrong, but because he's too strong, the law can't keep up."
Several people smiled wryly at the man's words. But it was no laughing matter.
The system problems exposed by the complete conqueror Magami Koichiro could eventually involve them as well.
The eighteen were recognizing that anew.
◇
The agenda shifted to the handling of rare materials.
Among materials obtained from dungeons, there are those difficult to replace with existing technology.
Industry, medicine, energy.
Rare materials used in various fields were important resources for the state as well.
Seeking stable supply had a certain rationality. However, the question of a material being important and the question of who owned it were separate. The legal experts explained that the acquirer's ownership did not immediately transfer to the state simply because of the material's importance.
If necessary, methods such as purchase or priority contracts could be considered. Of course, the possibility of future legal amendments or institutional changes could not be denied. However, even in that case, there were issues to consider, such as protection of property rights and compensation.
Many of the eighteen showed understanding for the state needing rare materials itself.
In the first place, selling obtained materials was their daily business. If needed, they should buy at fair conditions. The problem was the acquirer's rights being disregarded simply because something was nationally important. To dive into dungeons, one had to bear commensurate costs and dangers.
Purchase and maintenance of equipment.
Supplies needed for clearing.
The risk of injury or aftereffects.
And the possibility of losing one's life.
As a result of bearing such burdens, they obtained materials and rewards.
It was not merely something picked up. It was the result of work obtained through activities as a hunter.
"...Hey."
The man from Chugoku spoke up.
"Can I ask one thing?"
What the man confirmed was whether, under the current law, the state could unilaterally take away the materials they obtained. The lawyer explained that ownership would not transfer simply because of the material's importance. However, he could not say absolutely that future legal amendments or institutional changes would never happen. Hearing that answer, the man was silent for a while. Then he looked around at those present.
"I, you see, want to dive freely on my own and earn freely."
The gazes of the eighteen gathered on him.
"I hate being ordered around, and I don't like troublesome socializing. That's why I've done things this way until now."
The man tapped the documents on the table with his finger.
"But that and this are different, right?"
There was no languor in his voice now.
"I dived myself, defeated the monsters myself, and brought it back myself."
The man continued.
"If some random someone later comes up with a plausible reason and tries to snatch it away..."
He paused once.
"Can you all just stand by and watch that?"
The conference room fell silent.
The man looked around at the eighteen in turn.
"We're doing this for business, right?"
It was a simple question. The reasons for diving into dungeons differed.
Some wanted to become stronger. Some wanted to explore unknown places.
Some had a sense of mission to protect their regions. But as hunters, they operated and earned rewards from their results. On that point, no one was different.
"If the state's in trouble, I'll listen. If they need something, they can buy it."
The man's voice grew slightly stronger.
"But having people other than us decide our business on their own—that's wrong."
No one argued against those words. Whether they valued cooperation with the JHA or preferred independent activity, they were the same in that they bore danger as hunters and made a living from the results. They had no intention of refusing cooperation in national crises.
Nor did they intend to disregard the public importance of rare materials. However, they could not accept their own intentions or legitimate rights being ignored on those grounds.
The male hunter from Tohoku nodded quietly.
"I agree. The JHA has taken care of me, and I intend to continue cooperating. But I'm not about to leave everything, including how the results of my work are handled, up to them."
With those words as a trigger, the other participants also expressed agreement one after another.
The female hunter from Hokkaido also stated that whether they dove or not should ultimately be decided by themselves. The opinions of the eighteen aligned in a clear form for the first time.
Having confirmed that, the man from Chugoku sat back deeply in his chair once more.
"...Well, that's how it is."
And he added.
"I hate forming groups. But when it comes to protecting my business, that's different."
At those words, small laughter leaked from various parts of the conference room.
◇
In the subsequent discussion, concrete consideration was given to future responses.
What the eighteen sought was by no means complicated.
To operate by their own will. To have the results obtained as a consequence of bearing danger treated fairly. If cooperation was to be requested, to have the conditions and responsibilities clarified.
However, whether such ideas were legitimate and to what extent they were guaranteed as rights under current law and future systems were separate issues. The legal experts explained the need to organize them as concrete points of debate rather than emotional reactions. Also, regarding the opinion inquiry with active hunters previously conducted by the JHA, confirmation was made once more. After the first expert committee meeting, the JHA had sought opinions from active hunters on cooperation with the state, activity obligations, the qualification system, danger assessment, compensation, and so on.
Many of the eighteen had also responded from their respective standpoints.
However, none had a sufficient grasp of how the opinions they submitted had ultimately been examined. Of course, not all submitted opinions are adopted. Nor is it guaranteed that explanations will be given for individual responses. Even so, confirming how the opinions of those involved were handled had meaning. The meeting decided to continue examining the specific scope of application of the Magami Law, the distinction between emergency and normal-time obligations, the effectiveness of qualification suspension, and the rights of acquirers of rare materials. In addition, the decision-making procedures of the JHA's upper management, the division of authority with the Ministry of Non-Biological Countermeasures, and the relationship between complete conquerors' privileges and the current system would also be organized with the cooperation of the legal experts.
All were issues directly concerning their future activities. And the last thing left was the question of how the eighteen would communicate with each other going forward.
The enforcement of the law was yet to come.
Once the system began operating, new problems could arise.
Gathering all eighteen every time would be difficult. However, if each responded separately, they would end up seeking individual explanations for the same problem repeatedly. As a result of discussion, a policy was settled: normally continue their respective activities, and share information when common problems arose. Whether to establish a formal organization was not yet decided. Nor would they put someone forward as a representative and entrust all decisions to them. The procedures for jointly submitting opinions were also left as a matter for future consideration.
Even so, there was no objection to the eighteen continuously sharing information and obtaining the cooperation of legal experts as necessary. Thus, the first general meeting arrived at one conclusion. They would continue to communicate with each other regarding issues concerning their work and rights.
And they would organize their questions about the system and seek necessary explanations. It was by no means a grand declaration. However, for the eighteen who had operated independently in various regions until now, it was a definite change.
◇
By the time the meeting ended, it was completely evening outside.
The participants began preparing for their journeys home.
Those returning to Tokyo. Those heading to Kansai. Those going further afield.
From tomorrow, their usual activities awaited them again.
They had not accomplished anything in this one day.
The law had not changed. Their relationship with the JHA had not changed.
Even so, it was different from before. The S-rank hunters, of whom there were only eighteen in Japan.
All eighteen of them had come to know each other's thoughts and discussed common problems.
Differences of opinion remained. Their activity policies and values were each different.
But at least one thing all of them could not compromise on.
They would not accept having the results they obtained by bearing danger taken away without just cause. And they would not accept having how they did their work decided without them.
The eighteen were not yet one organization.
However, from that day onward, they were no longer the isolated eighteen.
◇
Meanwhile, at that time.
At JHA headquarters, an additional report was being given regarding the sighting information of S-rank hunters in Nagoya. As a result of cross-referencing information gathered from various regions, it was highly likely that all eighteen S-rank hunters in Japan had stayed in Nagoya.
However, the purpose of the meeting remained unconfirmed.
It was not an event hosted by the JHA.
It was not a convocation from an administrative organ.
There was no formal explanation to the regional branches either.
One of the executives who received the report spoke while looking at the documents.
"...Why is there no contact to us?"
The person in charge hesitated for a moment.
Then answered cautiously.
"If this gathering is private, prior reporting to the JHA is not necessarily required."
The executive silently returned his gaze to the documents.
There, the names of eighteen people were lined up.
All the S-rank hunters in Japan.
What had they discussed?
What had they decided?
Or had they decided nothing?
About none of it did JHA headquarters know anything.
Just one thing was certain.
The eighteen who had operated individually in various regions until now had met face-to-face without going through the JHA.
That fact alone was no longer in doubt.